On piecewise models and species–area patterns
Authors:
Open Access
- 2 July 2019
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Wiley in Ecology and Evolution
- Vol. 9 (14) , 8351-8361
Abstract
Aim: Area thresholds, at which the form of the species–area relationship (SAR) changes abruptly, have played an important role in the theoretical framework of conservation biogeography and biodiversity research. The application of piecewise regressions has been advocated as a rigorous statistical technique to identify such thresholds within SARs, but a large variety of piecewise models remains untested. We explore the prevalence and number of thresholds in SARs and examine whether the currently widely used method for detecting the small island effect (SIE) is robust.Location: Global.Taxon: We consider all multicellular taxa based on the criteria of datasets selection.Methods: We apply 15 regression models, including linear regression and piecewise regressions with two and three segments to 68 global island datasets that are sourced from the literature.Results: The number of area thresholds in SARs varied among groups and correlated positively with area range of a studied system. Under the AIC or AICc criterion, three‐segment piecewise models were more prevalent, whereas under the BIC criterion, two‐segment piecewise models were more prevalent. From the results of Aegean Sea isopods, West Indies herpetofauna, and Australian Islands mammals, we found evidence that the traditional criteria for detection of SIEs are not robust.Main conclusions: Our study demonstrates that (a) to detect an SIE, the comparison should use as many models as possible, including not only variants with and without a left‐horizontal part, but also those with two and more segments; (b) naive use of the traditional two‐segment piecewise regressions may cause poor estimations of both slope and breakpoint values; (c) the number of thresholds increases with the area range of a studied system; (d) conservation biologists and applied ecologists should determine the number of area thresholds when estimating the precise species–area patterns and making management strategies in fragmented landscapes.Keywords
Funding Information
- Hebei Normal University (L2018B21)
This publication has 48 references indexed in Scilit:
- Detecting the small island effect and nestedness of herpetofauna of the West IndiesEcology and Evolution, 2016
- The Anthropocene concept in ecology and conservationTrends in Ecology & Evolution, 2015
- Robust methods for detecting a small island effectDiversity and Distributions, 2010
- Ecological thresholds: an assessment of methods to identify abrupt changes in species–habitat relationshipsEcography, 2009
- To Fit or Not to Fit? A Poorly Fitting Procedure Produces Inconsistent Results When the Species–Area Relationship is used to Locate HotspotsBiodiversity and Conservation, 2006
- The search for fragmentation thresholds in a Southern Sydney SuburbBiological Conservation, 2005
- Subsidized Island Biogeography Hypothesis: another new twist on an old theoryEcology Letters, 2001
- How much habitat is enough?Biological Conservation, 2001
- Munroe revisited: a survey of West Indian butterfly faunas and their species-area relationshipGlobal Ecology and Biogeography, 1998
- Lots of Weeds: Insular Phytogeography of Vacant Urban LotsJournal of Biogeography, 1979