Mapping development in students’ understanding of vision using a cognitive structural model
- 1 January 1998
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Taylor & Francis in International Journal of Science Education
- Vol. 20 (1) , 45-66
Abstract
This exploratory study took two items, which were designed to ascertain children's understanding of the phenomenon of ‘seeing’, and used them to gather data over the K‐10 age range. One item was adapted from an earlier large‐scale survey by Adams et al. (1990); the other was based on a set of metaphors for ‘seeing’ designed by Guesne (1985). The data gathered were analysed in the context of a cognitive structural model. This analysis showed that, in relation to the concept of vision, the cognitive model selected was able to account for the ‘normal’ developmental sequence, as well as indicate some possible sequences which might help to explain the ‘alternative framework’ phenomenon in this case. There seems to be sufficient evidence from this study to warrant more detailed research in two directions. The first, replicating with a larger sample, the variables discussed in this paper, and the second, carrying out exploratory studies on concepts in other areas of science which have also documented the ‘alternative framework’ phenomenon. The results from this line of research would be invaluable to science educators who are interested in devising applications for classroom teaching, learning, assessment and curriculum development.Keywords
This publication has 8 references indexed in Scilit:
- On the identification of principles in science that might inform research into students’ beliefs about natural phenomenaInternational Journal of Science Education, 1995
- Images in mirrors: Recollections, alternative explanations and modes of cognitive functioningResearch in Science Education, 1994
- Making Sense of Secondary Science1994
- Towards a theoretical basis for students' alternative frameworks in science and for science teachingResearch in Science Education, 1993
- Young children's (7‐11) ideas about light and their developmentInternational Journal of Science Education, 1993
- Students' understanding of concepts related to evaporationResearch in Science Education, 1992
- Genetic epistemological notes on recent research into children's understanding of lightInternational Journal of Science Education, 1991
- Mapping solutions to an early multiplication word problemMathematics Education Research Journal, 1990