Rethinking areas of endemism and barriers: perspectives for a causal historical biogeography and a critique of Schultz and Cracraft (2024)
Open Access
- 6 March 2026
- journal article
- Published by Wiley in Cladistics
- Vol. 42 (4) , 401-412
Abstract
Historical biogeography faces a persistent conceptual and methodological dilemma concerning the nature of its central analytical units. Using the recent proposal by Schultz and Cracraft ( Cladistics 40, 653) as a catalyst, this article critiques the argument that causal inference necessitates the replacement of areas of endemism with barriers, contending that such a forced dichotomy is both artificial and reductionist. It is postulated that modern methodological advances allow areas of endemism to be rigorously treated as dynamic and quantitatively testable hypotheses, thereby overcoming long‐standing objections that classify them as mere descriptive constructs. Conversely, an exclusive focus on barriers fundamentally underestimates the multifactorial nature of diversification, neglecting the structural role of dispersal and the complex spatiotemporal dynamism of isolating forces. Effective inference in historical biogeography demands an explicitly pluralistic and process‐agnostic perspective, recognizing areas and barriers as complementary, intersecting elements. This integrative approach is essential for accurately capturing the emergent complexity of biogeographic patterns, moving the discipline beyond the limitations of unifocal causal models.Keywords
This publication has 88 references indexed in Scilit:
- Southern Hemisphere coasts are biologically connected by frequent, long-distance rafting eventsCurrent Biology, 2022
- Analytical Approaches in Biogeography: Advances and Challenges2021
- Dispersal Reduction: Causes, Genomic Mechanisms, and Evolutionary ConsequencesTrends in Ecology & Evolution, 2020
- The Latitudinal Diversity Gradient: Novel Understanding through Mechanistic Eco-evolutionary ModelsTrends in Ecology & Evolution, 2019
- Areas of endemism in the Atlantic Forest: quantitative biogeography insights from orchid bees (Apidae: Euglossini)Apidologie, 2017
- A history of chorological categoriesHistory and Philosophy of the Life Sciences, 2016
- Species concepts should not conflict with evolutionary history, but often doStudies in History and Philosophy of Science Part C: Studies in History and Philosophy of Biological and Biomedical Sciences, 2008
- Geobiology and paleobiogeography: tracking the coevolution of the Earth and its biotaPalaeogeography, Palaeoclimatology, Palaeoecology, 2005
- The resurrection of oceanic dispersal in historical biogeographyTrends in Ecology & Evolution, 2005
- Ecosystems and the Biosphere as Complex Adaptive SystemsEcosystems, 1998