The Agency Paradox in Elite Education: Self-Efficacy and Learnability Among French Higher Education Students

Authors:
  • RGRaphaël Grasset
    Raphaël Grasset
  • ATAlban Torette
    Alban Torette
  • SASébastien Allain
    Sébastien Allain
  • SBStéphanie Benard
    Stéphanie Benard
  • FBFranck Tarpin Bernard
    Franck Tarpin Bernard

Abstract
This study validated the Personal Agency Scale and Learnability Scale with French students (n = 847) and examined relationships between self-efficacy, learnability, and personal agency within socio-cognitive theory. The Personal Agency Scale demonstrated a one-factor structure with acceptable to good reliability (ω = .71-.79). The Learnability Scale confirmed a three-factor structure (cognitive, affective, conative) with good reliability (ω = .73-.83). Programme Grande Ecole (PGE) students showed significantly lower agency and learnability scores compared to peers in other institutions, with both preparatory class and alternative pathway students scoring lower than their counterparts in other programs. Regression analyses revealed self-efficacy (β = .42-.50) and conative learnability (β = .26) as strongest agency predictors. Mediation analyses indicated self-efficacy significantly mediated relationships between all learnability dimensions and agency, with strongest effects for affective and conative dimensions (β = .19) compared to cognitive (β = .12) and total learnability (β = .08). Results suggest highly selective educational environments may constrain perceived agency regardless of preparatory class experience, emphasizing the importance of fostering autonomy and self-efficacy alongside academic excellence.

This publication has 31 references indexed in Scilit: