Superior Live Birth Rates, Reducing Sperm DNA Fragmentation (SDF), and Lowering Miscarriage Rates by Using Testicular Sperm Versus Ejaculates in Intracytoplasmic Sperm Injection (ICSI) Cycles from Couples with High SDF: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis
Authors:
- Marina Cano-ExtremeraMCMarina Cano-Extremera
- Irene HervasIHIrene Hervas
- Alma Gisbert IranzoAIAlma Gisbert Iranzo
- Mar Falquet GuillemMGMar Falquet Guillem
- María Gil JuliáMJMaría Gil Juliá
- Ana Navarro-GomezlechonANAna Navarro-Gomezlechon
- Rosa Pacheco-RendónRPRosa Pacheco-Rendón
- Nicolás Garrido PuchaltNPNicolás Garrido Puchalt
Open Access
Abstract
This study aimed to compare sperm DNA fragmentation (SDF) levels between ejaculate and testicular sperm and evaluate clinical outcomes of intracytoplasmic sperm injection (ICSI) cycles using testicular sperm (T-ICSI) versus ejaculate sperm (E-ICSI) in males with high ejaculate SDF, prior ICSI failures, or severe male infertility. A systematic review of major databases and a subsequent meta-analysis were performed to compare clinical outcomes in men with high SDF, oligozoospermia, or prior ICSI failures undergoing T-ICSI or E-ICSI. Thirteen studies met the inclusion criteria. Outcomes analyzed included SDF levels, fertilization rate (FR), clinical pregnancy rate (CPR), live birth rate (LBR) per embryo transfer (ET), and miscarriage rate (MR) per pregnancy. The mean difference (MD) and odds ratio (OR) were calculated for each outcome. Paired assessments of SDF showed significantly lower levels in testicular sperm compared to ejaculated sperm (MD = −25.42 [−31.47, −17.30], p < 0.00001). While no significant difference in FR was observed in T-ICSI cycles overall (OR = 0.94 [0.74, 1.20]), a subgroup analysis revealed significantly higher FR with E-ICSI in men with oligozoospermia and no prior ICSI failures (OR = 0.61 [0.52, 0.71], p < 0.00001). CPR was significantly higher in T-ICSI cycles (OR = 2.13 [1.35, 3.36], p < 0.001; n = 540 ET), along with a significantly lower MR (OR = 0.31 [0.14, 0.70], p = 0.004; n = 35) and increased LBR (OR = 2.40 [1.32, 4.36], p = 0.004; n = 446 ET). In conclusion, using testicular sperm in cases of elevated ejaculate SDF, oligozoospermia, or prior failed ICSI cycles enhances the selection of sperm with lower DNA damage, leading to improved pregnancy rates, reduced miscarriage rates, and higher live birth rates. However, the studies included were rated as having a moderate to serious risk of bias. Further well-designed randomized controlled trials are necessary to confirm these findings with stronger evidence.Keywords
This publication has 66 references indexed in Scilit:
- Does Testicular Sperm Improve Intracytoplasmic Sperm Injection Outcomes for Nonazoospermic Infertile Men with Elevated Sperm DNA Fragmentation? A Systematic Review and Meta-analysisEuropean Urology Focus, 2023
- Switching to testicular sperm after a previous ICSI failure with ejaculated sperm significantly improves blastocyst quality without increasing aneuploidy riskJournal of Assisted Reproduction and Genetics, 2022
- Sperm DNA fragmentation on the day of fertilization is not associated with embryologic or clinical outcomes after IVF/ICSIJournal of Assisted Reproduction and Genetics, 2019
- Potential of testicular sperm to support embryonic development to the blastocyst stage is comparable to that of ejaculated spermJournal of Assisted Reproduction and Genetics, 2018
- In vitro fertilization–intracytoplasmic sperm injection outcome in patients with a markedly high DNA fragmentation index (>50%)Fertility and Sterility, 2013
- Intracytoplasmic sperm injection outcome of ejaculated versus extracted testicular spermatozoa in cryptozoospermic menFertility and Sterility, 2013
- Effect of sperm DNA fragmentation on pregnancy outcome depends on oocyte qualityFertility and Sterility, 2011
- Sperm DNA fragmentation: mechanisms of origin, impact on reproductive outcome, and analysisFertility and Sterility, 2010
- Testicular spermatozoa have statistically significantly lower DNA damage compared with ejaculated spermatozoa in patients with unsuccessful oral antioxidant treatmentFertility and Sterility, 2010
- Pregnancies after intracytoplasmic injection of single spermatozoon into an oocyteThe Lancet, 1992