Preservation Rhinoplasty: Open or Closed?
- 20 April 2022
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Aesthetic Surgery Journal
- Vol. 42 (9) , 990-1008
Abstract
Background: Preservation rhinoplasty (PR) is an evolving philosophy. Objectives: The open approach was initially utilized, but the author felt a closed approach might be of benefit in certain patients. Methods: A total 162 primary rhinoplasty cases were studied retrospectively between May and November 2020. One hundred cases had at least 1 year of follow-up. Patients had follow-up at 1 week, 1 month, 3 months, and 1 year after surgery. Technical details were recorded, including dissection planes, preservation of the dorsum (DP) vs component reductions, surface vs foundational DP techniques, and open vs closed approach. Results: One hundred patients had at least 1 year of follow-up. Fifty-six patients underwent an open approach and 44 a closed approach. Eighty-three patients had preservation of the dorsal soft tissue envelope. All patients who underwent a closed approach had preservation of the dorsal soft tissue envelope. Sixty-seven patients underwent DP, with 38 receiving surface techniques and 29 undergoing impaction techniques. Thirty-three patients underwent structural rhinoplasty with piezoelectric osteotomies and mid-vault reconstruction. All structural cases were performed employing an open approach. Four revision surgeries were necessary. Conclusions: Open and closed approaches have indications depending on the tip and dorsal deformities. A closed PR is favored with thin skin, minimal dorsal modification, osseocartilaginous preservation (foundation techniques), less complex tip deformities, and overprojected noses. An open PR is favored for extensive dorsal modification, S-shaped nasal bones, complex tip deformities, and tip augmentation. Structural dorsal rhinoplasty is always conducted open and preferred for complex dorsal deformities and severe septal deviations. Level of Evidence: 4:Keywords
This publication has 18 references indexed in Scilit:
- A Modified Dorsal Split Preservation Technique for Nasal Humps with Minor Bony Component: A Preliminary ReportAesthetic Plastic Surgery, 2019
- Decision Making in Preservation Rhinoplasty: A 100 Case Series With One-Year Follow-UpAesthetic Surgery Journal, 2019
- Open Piezo Preservation Rhinoplasty: A Case Report of the New Rhinoplasty ApproachFacial Plastic Surgery, 2019
- Reassessing Surgical Management of the Bony Vault in RhinoplastyAesthetic Surgery Journal, 2018
- Dorsal Preservation: The Push Down Technique ReassessedAesthetic Surgery Journal, 2018
- Rhinoplasty2018
- Spare Roof Technique: A Middle Third New TechniqueFacial Plastic Surgery, 2016
- The Role of Piezoelectric Instrumentation in Rhinoplasty SurgeryAesthetic Surgery Journal, 2015
- Rhinoplasty: Surface Aesthetics and Surgical TechniquesAesthetic Surgery Journal, 2013
- A Complete Subperichondrial Dissection Technique for Rhinoplasty With Management of the Nasal LigamentsAesthetic Surgery Journal, 2012