Early mobilization versus plaster immobilization of simple elbow dislocations: a cost analysis of the FuncSiE multicenter randomized clinical trial
Authors:
- FuncSiE Trial InvestigatorsFIFuncSiE Trial Investigators
- Esther M. M. Van LieshoutELEsther M. M. Van Lieshout
- Gijs I. T. IordensGIGijs I. T. Iordens
- Suzanne PolinderSPSuzanne Polinder
- Denise EygendaalDEDenise Eygendaal
- Michael H. J. VerhofstadMVMichael H. J. Verhofstad
- Niels W. L. SchepNSNiels W. L. Schep
- Dennis Den HartogDHDennis Den Hartog
Open Access
- 23 November 2019
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Springer Nature in Archives of orthopaedic and trauma surgery
- Vol. 140 (7) , 877-886
Abstract
Introduction: The primary aim was to assess and compare the total costs (direct health care costs and indirect costs due to loss of production) after early mobilization versus plaster immobilization in patients with a simple elbow dislocation. It was hypothesized that early mobilization would not lead to higher direct and indirect costs. Materials and methods: This study used data of a multicenter randomized clinical trial (FuncSiE trial). From August 25, 2009 until September 18, 2012, 100 adult patients with a simple elbow dislocation were recruited and randomized to early mobilization (immediate motion exercises; n = 48) or 3 weeks plaster immobilization (n = 52). Patients completed questionnaires on health-related quality of life [EuroQoL-5D (EQ-5D) and Short Form-36 (SF-36 PCS and SF-36 MCS)], health care use, and work absence. Follow-up was 1 year. Primary outcome were the total costs at 1 year. Analysis was by intention to treat. Results: There were no significant differences in EQ-5D, SF-36 PCS, and SF-36 MCS between the two groups. Mean total costs per patient were €3624 in the early mobilization group versus €7072 in the plaster group (p = 0.094). Shorter work absenteeism in the early mobilization group (10 versus 18 days; p = 0.027) did not lead to significantly lower costs for loss of productivity (€1719 in the early mobilization group versus €4589; p = 0.120). Conclusion: From a clinical and a socio-economic point of view, early mobilization should be the treatment of choice for a simple elbow dislocation. Plaster immobilization has inferior results at almost double the cost.Keywords
Funding Information
- European Society for Surgery of the Shoulder and the Elbow (Fifth SECEC/ESSSE Research Grant 2010)
This publication has 19 references indexed in Scilit:
- Trends in incidence and costs of injuries to the shoulder, arm and wrist in The Netherlands between 1986 and 2008BMC Public Health, 2013
- Incidence of Elbow Dislocations in the United States PopulationJournal of Bone and Joint Surgery, 2012
- Func tional treatment versus plaster for si mple el bow dislocations (FuncSiE): a randomized trialBMC Musculoskeletal Disorders, 2010
- Complex and Unstable Simple Elbow Dislocations: A Review and Quantitative Analysis of Individual Patient Data~!2009-10-23~!2009-12-20~!2010-02-17~!The Open Orthopaedics Journal, 2010
- Simple elbow dislocations: a systematic review of the literatureArchives of orthopaedic and trauma surgery, 2009
- Simple elbow dislocation among adults: A comparative study of two different methods of treatmentInjury, 2007
- Guidelines for the Conduction of Follow-up Studies Measuring Injury-Related DisabilityJournal of Trauma: Injury, Infection & Critical Care, 2007
- Management of simple elbow dislocationsLangenbeck's Archives of Surgery, 1999
- The friction cost method for measuring indirect costs of diseaseJournal of Health Economics, 1995
- The MOS 36-ltem Short-Form Health Survey (SF-36)Medical Care, 1992