When AI evaluates its own work: Validating learner-initiated, AI-generated physics practice problems
Authors:
Open Access
- 9 April 2026
- journal article
- Published by American Physical Society (APS) in Physical Review Physics Education Research
- Vol. 22 (1)
Abstract
Large language models (LLMs) can now generate physics practice problems in real time, yet the educational value of these items hinges on rapid, reliable postgeneration vetting. In this exploratory study, we investigated which automated checks are both technically feasible and pedagogically meaningful when exercises are produced on demand within a chatbot interface. A cohort of 34 introductory-physics students generated and attempted 543 practice problems during exam preparation. Each item was labeled by an expert on a wide range of quality attributes and presented to the learners in pairs to record their preference. We then (i) benchmarked three commodity LLMs as “judges” against the expert labels, (ii) quantified which attributes predict student choice via random-forest models, and (iii) triangulated these results with free-form exit surveys. Only a small subset of the original metric items proved necessary to reliably address student preferences either directly or by proxy. The study demonstrates that scalable formative assessment does not require exhaustive scoring: a carefully curated core of structural and learner-visible checks is sufficient to ensure both technical soundness and user appeal. The findings provide a practical blueprint for deploying real-time, AI-generated practice in physics and other quantitative disciplines.Keywords
All Related Versions
This publication has 53 references indexed in Scilit:
- Can ChatGPT pass a physics degree? Making a case for reformation of assessment of undergraduate degreesEuropean Journal of Physics, 2024
- A survey on students’ use of AI at a technical universityDiscover Education, 2024
- ChatGPT as a tool for honing teachers’ Socratic dialogue skillsPhysics Education, 2024
- Personalizing Algebra to Students’ Individual Interests in an Intelligent Tutoring System: Moderators of ImpactInternational Journal of Artificial Intelligence in Education, 2018
- Transforming Assessment2018
- Using cognitive apprenticeship framework and multiple-possibility problems to enhance epistemic cognitionAIP Conference Proceedings, 2009
- A review and critique of context-based physics instruction and assessmentEducational Research Review, 2008
- Comparison of student performance using web and paper‐based homework in college‐level physicsJournal of Research in Science Teaching, 2003
- Random ForestsMachine Learning, 2001
- Graph drawing by force‐directed placementSoftware: Practice and Experience, 1991