Systematic Performance Comparison of (Duobinary)-PAM-2,4 Signaling under Light and Strong Opto-Electronic Bandwidth Conditions
Authors:
- Ramón Gutiérrez-CastrejónRamón Gutiérrez-Castrejón
- Ghulam SaberGSGhulam Saber
- Samiul AlamSASamiul Alam
- Zhenping XingZXZhenping Xing
- Eslam El-FikyEEEslam El-Fiky
- Daniel E. Ceballos-HerreraDCDaniel E. Ceballos-Herrera
- Fabio CavaliereFabio Cavaliere
- Gemma Vall-LloseraGVGemma Vall-Llosera
- Luca GiorgiLGLuca Giorgi
- Stephane LessardSLStephane Lessard
- Robert BrunnerRBRobert Brunner
- David V. PlantDPDavid V. Plant
Open Access
Abstract
We present a systematic comparison of PAM-2 (NRZ), Duobinary-PAM-2, PAM-4, and Duobinary-PAM-4 (duo-quaternary) signaling in the context of short-reach photonic communications systems using a Mach–Zehnder modulator as transmitter. The effect on system performance with a relaxed and constrained system’s opto-electronic bandwidth is analyzed for bit rates ranging from 20 to 116 Gb/s. In contrast to previous analyses, our approach employs the same experimental and simulation conditions for all modulation formats. Consequently, we were able to confidently determine the performance limits of each format for particular values of bit rate, system bandwidth, transmitter chirp, and fiber dispersion. We demonstrate that Duobinary-PAM-4 is a good signaling choice only for bandwidth-limited systems operating at relatively high speed. Otherwise, PAM-4 represents a more sensible choice. Moreover, our analysis put forward the existence of transition points: specific bit rate values where the BER versus bit rate curves for two different formats cross each other. They indicate the bit rate values where, for specific system conditions, switching from one modulation to another guarantees optimum performance. Their existence naturally led to the proposal of a format-selective transceiver, a component that, according to network conditions, operates with the most adequate modulation format. Since all analyzed modulations share similar implementation details, signaling switching is achieved by simply changing the sampling point and threshold count at the receiver, bringing flexibility to IM/DD-based optical networks.Keywords
Funding Information
- Dirección General de Asuntos del Personal Académico, Universidad Nacional Autónoma de México (IN103720)
- Nature et technologies (200755)
- RH Tomlinson Fellowship of McGill University (90025)
- SPIE Optics and Photonics Education Scholarship (2019)
This publication has 39 references indexed in Scilit:
- IM/DD-Based 112-Gb/s/lambda PAM-4 Transmission Using 18-Gbps DMLIEEE Photonics Journal, 2016
- Experimental study of PAM-4, CAP-16, and DMT for 100 Gb/s Short Reach Optical Transmission SystemsOptics Express, 2015
- Advanced modulation formats for 400-Gbps short-reach optical inter-connectionOptics Express, 2015
- Experimental study of 112 Gb/s short reach transmission employing PAM formats and SiP intensity modulator at 13 μmOptics Express, 2014
- A tutorial on the flexible optical networking paradigm: State of the art, trends, and research challengesProceedings of the IEEE, 2014
- Analytical investigation of optimization, performance bound, and chromatic dispersion tolerance of 4-amplitude-shifted-keying format2006
- Demonstration of negative dispersion fibers for DWDM metropolitan area networksIEEE Journal of Selected Topics in Quantum Electronics, 2001
- Multilevel signaling for increasing the reach of 10 Gb/s lightwave systemsJournal of Lightwave Technology, 1999
- An Analysis of the Capabilities of Polybinary Data TransmissionIEEE Transactions on Communications, 1965
- Correlative Digital Communication TechniquesIEEE Transactions on Communications, 1964