In the polarized sociopolitical context of the United States, K-12 teachers may increasingly find themselves in the crossfire of conservative rhetoric and legislation that run counter to the work of social justice and equity-centered efforts in education. This is a wicked problem for science teachers in particular, as science issues that have been considered largely settled in the scientific community—such as climate change, vaccine safety, and trust in the scientific enterprise—have a history of being called into question by conservative political platforms and constituents. In this chapter, we present an illustrative vignette of a science teacher who encountered this wicked problem in her teaching practice. We propose solutions in light of this vignette that may address this wicked problem by emphasizing changes in leadership practices and support for teachers at more systemic levels. Specifically, we focus on the role of school and district leadership in communicating with parents and community members about justifications for curricular decisions and supporting teachers' overall well-being. As wicked problems are—by definition—highly complex and likely to resist simple fixes, we view these solutions as partial but promising.