Innovative Approaches to Industrial Odour Monitoring: From Chemical Analysis to Predictive Models
Authors:
- Claudia FranchinaCFClaudia Franchina
- Amedeo Manuel CefalìACAmedeo Manuel Cefalì
- Martina GianottiMGMartina Gianotti
- Alessandro FrugisAFAlessandro Frugis
- Corrado CorradiCCCorrado Corradi
- Giulio De ProsperisGPGiulio De Prosperis
- Dario RonzioDRDario Ronzio
- Luca FerreroLuca Ferrero
- Ezio BolzacchiniEBEzio Bolzacchini
- Domenico CiprianoDomenico Cipriano
Open Access
- 21 November 2024
- journal article
- research article
- Published by MDPI AG in Atmosphere
- Vol. 15 (12) , 1401
Abstract
This study evaluated the reliability of an electronic nose in monitoring odour concentration near a wastewater treatment plant and examined the correlation between four sensor readings and odour intensity. The electronic nose chemical sensors are related to the concentration of the following chemical species: two values for the concentration of VOCs recorded via the PID sensor (VPID) and the EC sensor (VEC), and concentrations of sulfuric acid (VH2S) and benzene (VC6H6). Using Random Forest and least squares regression analysis, the study identifies VH2S and VC6H6 as key contributors to odour concentration (CcOD). Three Random Forest models (RF0, RF1, RF2), with different characteristics for splitting between the test set and the training set, were tested, with RF1 showing superior predictive performance due to its training approach. All models highlighted VH2S and VC6H6 as significant predictors, while VPID and VEC had less influence. A significant correlation between odour concentration and specific chemical sensor readings was found, particularly for VH2S and VC6H6. However, predicting odour concentrations below 1000 ouE/m3 proved challenging. Linear regression further confirmed the importance of VH2S and VC6H6, with a moderate R-squared value of 0.70, explaining 70% of the variability in odour concentration. The study demonstrated the effectiveness of combining Random Forest and least squares regression for robust and interpretable results. Future research should focus on expanding the dataset and incorporating additional variables to enhance model accuracy. The findings underscore the necessity of specific sensor training and standardised procedures for accurate odour monitoring and characterisation.Keywords
Funding Information
- Research Fund for the Italian Electrical System (3922-210-023—SFE LA.2.10-023, DM MITE n.337, 15.09.2022)
- Three-Year Research Plan 2022–2024 (3922-210-023—SFE LA.2.10-023, DM MITE n.337, 15.09.2022)
This publication has 52 references indexed in Scilit:
- A random forest guided tourTEST, 2016
- Conversion of the chemical concentration of odorous mixtures into odour concentration and odour intensity: A comparison of methodsAtmospheric Environment, 2016
- Marked changes in olfactory perception during early pregnancy: a prospective case–control study2014
- Measuring odours in the environment vs. dispersion modelling: A reviewAtmospheric Environment, 2013
- Online monitoring of volatile organic compound production and emission during sewage sludge compostingBioresource Technology, 2012
- Overview of random forest methodology and practical guidance with emphasis on computational biology and bioinformaticsWIREs Data Mining and Knowledge Discovery, 2012
- A comparative and critical evaluation of odour assessment methods on a landfill siteAtmospheric Environment, 2008
- Odor Determination at Wastewater Collection Systems: Olfactometry versus H2S AnalysesCLEAN – Soil, Air, Water, 2007
- Data analysis for electronic nose systemsMicrochimica Acta, 2006
- A brief history of electronic nosesSensors and Actuators B: Chemical, 1994