Students’ interactions with faculty members—not only in the classroom but also through the presence or absence of advising relationships—shape their graduate school experiences. Establishing high-quality advising relationships increases student success, particularly for students holding minoritized identities, yet institutional training and evaluation structures do not often prepare or reward faculty for such relationships. Utilizing a holistic advising approach and identity-focused lens, this chapter outlines how developing strong relationships and viewing students in their full humanity is imperative to implementing effective advising, supporting degree completion, and reimagining graduate education. Further, the chapter argues that employing an identity-focused lens extends holistic advising by incorporating students’ intersecting identities and lived experiences and confronting the systemic and pervasive -isms present in higher education. Advising vignettes showcase how identity dimensions influence advising dynamics and chronicle the strategies used to foster a quality holistic, identity-focused advising relationship and to promote a sense of belonging and success. Finally, the chapter offers recommendations to encourage holistic, identity-focused advising at the individual, departmental, and institutional levels.