Judicial Approaches to the Human Rights Act
Authors:
- David BonnerDBDavid Bonner
- Helen FenwickHFHelen Fenwick
- Sonia Harris-ShortSHSonia Harris-Short
- 1 July 2003
- journal article
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in International and Comparative Law Quarterly
- Vol. 52 (3) , 549-586
Abstract
The case law generated in just over two years' operation of the Human Rights Act 1998 (HRA), enables stocktaking rather than definitive appraisal.1 This article begins by recalling the markedly contrasting roles in United Kingdom law of the European Convention on Human Rights (ECHR) before and after the HRA, the better to appreciate judicial approaches to, and use of, the HRA in the areas surveyed. The second part of the article focuses on judicial use of key provisions of the HRA to interpret primary legislation said to conflict with one or more Convention rights and on judicial use of the power to make a declaration of incompatibility. It considers a selection of decisions, principally of the House of Lords and the Court of Appeal, which raise important points regarding the purpose and scope of the HRA as a constitutional document and indicate judicial uncertainty as to how the HRA should be conceptualised, interpreted and applied. With this emerging picture of a cautious and uncertain judiciary in mind, the final two sections of the article give detailed consideration to the post-HRA jurisprudence within two discrete areas of English law. Part III explores the impact of the HRA on judicial approaches to the clash between the freedoms of expression and assembly, on the one hand, and public order, on the other. Part IV considers the ‘use and abuse’ of the HRA and of Article 8 ECHR in private law family disputes. Finally, certain tentative conclusions as to the perhaps disappointing story of the HRA so far, will be proffered.Keywords
This publication has 10 references indexed in Scilit:
- Judicial Deference under the Human Rights ActThe Modern Law Review, 2002
- Parliamentary sovereignty and the new constitutional order: legislative freedom, political reality and conventionLegal Studies, 2002
- Judicial Sovereignty and the Human Rights Act 1998The Cambridge Law Journal, 2002
- Civil Liberties & Human Rights2002
- The United Kingdom's Human Rights Act 1998 in Theory and PracticeInternational and Comparative Law Quarterly, 2001
- TAKING CHILDREN ABROAD: HUMAN RIGHTS, WELFARE AND THE COURTSThe Cambridge Law Journal, 2001
- Reading down legislation under the Human Rights ActLegal Studies, 2000
- Reclaiming Public Ground: The Right to Peaceful AssemblyThe Modern Law Review, 2000
- The Right to Protest, the Human Rights Act and the Margin of AppreciationThe Modern Law Review, 1999
- The Human Rights Act 1998 and constitutional principlesLegal Studies, 1999