The Relationship Between Dental Students’ Assessment Ability and Preclinical and Academic Performance in Operative Dentistry
Authors:
- 1 March 2017
- journal article
- predoctoral dental-education
- Published by Wiley in Journal of Dental Education
- Vol. 81 (3) , 310-317
Abstract
Self‐assessment is a critical skill for health care professionals. Because these professionals must be lifelong, self‐directed learners and self‐regulating practitioners, the ability to self‐assess is essential for them. The aims of this study were to measure how dental students self‐assessed and peer‐assessed their performance in preclinical operative procedures and to evaluate any relationship between their assessment ability and preclinical skills or academic performance. The study was conducted from 2015 to 2016. Third‐year students at Harvard School of Dental Medicine self‐assessed their work on four preclinical practical exams: Class II amalgam preparation, Class II amalgam restoration, Class III composite preparation, and Class III composite restoration. Three faculty members graded the same preparations and restorations. The difference between the students’ self‐assessment and the mean faculty assessment was calculated as the student‐faculty (S‐F) gap. An absolute S‐F gap was also calculated with absolute values of differences. A total of 71 students completed these practical exams: 36 in the Class of 2016 and 35 in the Class of 2017. All 71 self‐assessments for each of the four practical exams were collected for a response rate of 100%. The results showed that the mean S‐F gap ranged from 2% to 8%, and the absolute S‐F gap ranged from 7% to 12%. Preclinical performance was correlated with self‐assessment accuracy. Low‐performing students significantly overestimated their self‐assessments compared to the rest of the class. High‐performing students had more accurate self‐assessments and tended to underestimate themselves. Overall, these results showed that the students had room for improving the accuracy of their self‐assessments.Keywords
This publication has 19 references indexed in Scilit:
- Agreement Among Dental Students, Peer Assessors, and Tutor in Assessing Students’ Competence in Preclinical SkillsJournal of Dental Education, 2015
- Levels of agreement between student and staff assessments of clinical skills in performing cavity preparation in artificial teethEuropean Journal of Dental Education, 2013
- Medical students’ self-assessment of performance: Results from three meta-analysesPatient Education and Counseling, 2011
- Peer‐group assessment of pre‐clinical operative skills in restorative dentistry and comparison with experienced assessorsEuropean Journal of Dental Education, 2008
- The effectiveness of self-assessment on the identification of learner needs, learner activity, and impact on clinical practice: BEME Guide no. 10Medical Teacher, 2008
- Knowing When to Look It Up: A New Conception of Self-Assessment AbilityAcademic Medicine, 2007
- An analysis of peer, self, and tutor assessment in problem-based learning tutorialsMedical Teacher, 2007
- Self-assessment, Self-direction, and the Self-regulating ProfessionalClinical Orthopaedics and Related Research, 2006
- Not knowing that they do not know: self‐assessment accuracy of third‐year medical studentsMedical Education, 2006
- How Can I Know What I Don't Know? Poor Self Assessment in a Well-Defined DomainAdvances in Health Sciences Education, 2004