Comparing modeling approaches for assessing priorities in international agricultural research
Open Access
- 20 February 2018
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Research Evaluation
- Vol. 27 (2) , 145-156
Abstract
This article examines how the estimated impacts of crop technologies vary with alternate methods and assumptions, and also discusses the implications of these differences for the design of studies to inform research prioritization. Drawing on international potato research, we show how foresight scenarios, realized by a multi-period global multi-commodity equilibrium model, can affect the estimated magnitudes of welfare impacts and the ranking of different potato research options, as opposed to the static, single-commodity, and country assumptions of the economic surplus model which is commonly used in priority setting studies. Our results suggest that the ranking of technologies is driven by the data used for their specification and is not affected by the foresight scenario examined. However, net benefits vary significantly in each scenario and are greatly overestimated when impacts on non-target countries are ignored. We also argue that the validity of the single-commodity assumption underpinning the economic surplus model is case-specific and depends on the interventions examined and on the objectives and criteria included in a priority setting study.Keywords
Funding Information
- Bill and Melinda Gates Foundation (OPP1009468)
This publication has 26 references indexed in Scilit:
- The representative concentration pathways: an overviewClimatic Change, 2011
- The HadGEM2-ES implementation of CMIP5 centennial simulationsGeoscientific Model Development, 2011
- Exploring strategic priorities for regional agricultural R&D investments in East and Central AfricaAgricultural Economics, 2010
- Priority setting for research on aquatic resources: an application of modified economic surplus analysis to natural resource systemsAgricultural Economics, 2008
- The DSSAT cropping system modelEuropean Journal of Agronomy, 2003
- Prospects for food demand and supply in Central AsiaFood Policy, 2000
- Global projections for root and tuber crops to the year 2020Food Policy, 2000
- Targeting poverty alleviation in priority setting for agricultural researchFood Policy, 2000
- China's Food Economy to the Twenty‐first Century: Supply, Demand, and TradeEconomic Development and Cultural Change, 1999
- Agricultural research priority setting under multiple objectives: an example from ZimbabweAgricultural Economics, 1999