A scale-flexible framework for estimating underground soil loss and reconstructing sediment budgets

Authors:
  • QKQihua Ke
    Qihua Ke
  • PZPengzhi Zhao
    Pengzhi Zhao
  • KOKristof Van Oost
    Kristof Van Oost
  • JHJianghu He
    Jianghu He
  • 晨赵晨淞 赵
    晨淞 赵
  • JDJianzhi Dong
    Jianzhi Dong
  • KZKeli Zhang
    Keli Zhang
  • GWGuangqian Wang
    Guangqian Wang

Abstract
Underground soil loss (USL) represents a poorly quantified and overlooked component of the erosion-transport-deposition cycle in Earth’s critical zone. In karst and karst-like landscapes, surface-derived sediment can enter the underground domain through fissures, sinkholes, caves, and conduits. Existing erosion and sediment-delivery frameworks mainly describe detachment, lateral transport, and deposition at the land surface, leaving underground diversion and storage poorly represented. Within the complex subsurface erosion–sediment delivery system, we focus on USL originating from surface erosion, defined as the net transfer of surface-eroded soil and sediment to the underground domain, where it escapes conventional surface-based monitoring. Direct underground monitoring is spatially restricted, subject to uncertain subsurface drainage boundaries, and unable to quantify dispersed underground deposition at large scales. We therefore develop a sediment-delivery-ratio (SDR)-based framework to estimate the relative contribution and absolute magnitude of USL using only surface-based data. A proof-of-concept application to two nested karst catchments yields higher USL estimates than outlet-based estimates because the framework additionally accounts for underground deposition. Both approaches indicate a greater relative contribution of USL at the larger catchment scale, consistent with documented USL pathways and sediment-fingerprinting evidence. Together, the theoretical derivation, conceptual demonstration, and case study support the framework’s physical plausibility and diagnostic utility. The framework offers a first-order, scalable tool for incorporating underground sediment transfer and deposition into soil-erosion assessments and sediment and carbon budgets in karst and rock-pseudokarst regions, potentially advancing understanding of these processes from regional to global scales.

This publication has 43 references indexed in Scilit: