An experiment was conducted on intact algal assemblages of stream periphyton to test their response to fluctuating and constant light regimes having the same mean intensity. The light regimes (in μmol·m−2·s−1) were constant light at 100, light fluctuating between 50 and 150 with a period of 5 min, and light fluctuating between 10 and 460 with periods of either 4:1 or 8:2 min. Compared to the rates measured under 100 in μmol·m−2·s−1 constant light conditions, fluctuations ranging between 50 and 150 in μmol·m−2·s−1 with a 5‐min period produced a 23% greater rate of photosynthesis. Conversely, fluctuations between 10 and 460 in μmol·m−2·s−1 led to a 59%–74% decrease in photosynthetic activity. Detailed examination of periphytic algal responses to fluctuating light revealed that higher light intensities produced steeper photosynthesis/time slopes, but it was the combined interaction with lower light intensity that ultimately determined overall photosynthetic rate for a given light regime. This study offers compelling evidence that variable light regimes have important consequences for algal photosynthesis in natural streams.