A systematic review using a multi-layered criteria framework for assessing the validity and reliability of velocity monitoring devices in resistance training
Open Access
- 8 September 2025
- journal article
- review article
- Published by Public Library of Science (PLoS) in PLOS ONE
- Vol. 20 (9) , e0324606
Abstract
Background: Velocity-Based Training (VBT) is an emerging method in resistance training for objectively prescribing and monitoring training intensity and neuromuscular function. Given its growing popularity, assessing the validity and reliability of VBT devices is critical for strength and conditioning coaches. Objective: The primary purpose of this review was twofold: (1) to identify and address methodological gaps in current assessments of VBT device validity and reliability, and (2) to propose and apply a novel, multi-layered, criterion-based framework—developed in collaboration with statisticians and domain experts—for evaluating these devices. Methods: A systematic search was conducted in PubMed, Scopus, and SPORTDiscus following PRISMA guidelines, focusing on original research studies published before February 2024 that assessed VBT device validity or reliability. Out of 568 studies identified, 75 met the inclusion criteria. Results: Among the included studies, 66 investigated device validity and 56 examined reliability, with some studies addressing both aspects. Notably, only 5 of the 66 validity studies met all of the proposed criteria, while just 16 of the 56 reliability investigations satisfied the required statistical thresholds defined by our framework. These findings highlight significant methodological variability and underscore the need for more standardized evaluation practices. Conclusions: This review systematically evaluated the validity and reliability of various VBT devices and introduced a robust, multi-layered framework for their assessment. By integrating statistician-led and domain expert-led criteria, the framework offers a standardized approach that enhances the precision of device evaluation. Promising tools identified include the GymAware LPT, Perch Motion Capture Single Camera System, Flex optical device, and VmaxPro. Future research should build upon and refine this methodology to further standardize study designs, improve data reporting, and ultimately support more informed decision-making in sports technology and training practice.Keywords
This publication has 110 references indexed in Scilit:
- The Validity and Reliability of Commercially Available Resistance Training Monitoring Devices: A Systematic ReviewSports Medicine, 2021
- Updating conceptions of validity and reliabilityResearch in Social and Administrative Pharmacy, 2020
- Validity and reliability assessment of 3-D camera-based capture barbell velocity tracking deviceJournal of Science and Medicine in Sport, 2020
- Maximum velocity during loaded countermovement jumps obtained with an accelerometer, linear encoder and force platform: A comparison of technologiesJournal of Biomechanics, 2019
- Reproducibility and Repeatability of Five Different Technologies for Bar Velocity Measurement in Resistance TrainingAnnals of Biomedical Engineering, 2019
- Is the high-speed camera-based method a plausible option for bar velocity assessment during resistance training?Measurement, 2019
- Applied Sport Science of Australian Football: A Systematic ReviewSports Medicine, 2018
- Effective use of Pearson's product–moment correlation coefficientAnimal Behaviour, 2014
- Why the P-value culture is bad and confidence intervals a better alternativeOsteoarthritis and Cartilage, 2012
- Understanding the error of our ways: Mapping the concepts of validity and reliabilityNursing Outlook, 2006