This chapter focuses on the essential questions of the STEAM curriculum, namely, what is to be taught, how to productively teach it, and the purpose of teaching it. The chapter is organized as follows. First, we provide a comprehensive review of scholarly literature on the pedagogical use of STEAM in support of ELs. We then examine the practices of five secondary teachers who set out to support English learners (ELs) through adoption of an integrated science–art curricular approach. It was found that, despite having received the same professional training and pursuing a common educational goal, the teachers’ STEAM lessons varied considerably in terms of content and how art was merged with STEM (instructional sequence, pedagogical strategies). While in some lessons art was incorporated from the onset and constituted an integral part of classroom concept formation, in others, aesthetically rich experiences were simply added to the end as aesthetically rich illustration of previously taught concepts. Moreover, some teachers resorted to divergent artistic tasks (open-ended drawing), whereas others opted for convergent tasks that emphasized copy and imitation. It is argued that teachers need access to professional development that can help them develop more sophisticated views of art as a form of inquiry that can be more deeply integrated into STEM lessons as an epistemic tool for engaging students in content exploration and concept development. Using more conceptually profound art-integrated tasks can help ELs better connect with complicated topics in a creative and personal manner, making learning more relevant, engaging, and accessible.