Multiple Elevations on Symptom Validity Indicators Embedded in Psychopathology Screening Measures Improves Specificity When Classifying Invalid Symptom Overreporting
Authors:
- 30 September 2026
- journal article
- research article
- Published by SAGE Publications in Assessment
Abstract
Traditional symptom validity tests (SVT) are crucial yet costly components of routine evaluations. Embedded overreporting SVT cutoffs in commonly used psychopathology screeners exist, but it is unclear how multiple elevations across these measures impact detection accuracy. This study explored if the convergence of elevations across three embedded SVTs, Beck Depression Inventory-Second Edition, Beck Anxiety Inventory, and Posttraumatic Stress Disorder Checklist for DSM-5, improves invalidity detection accuracy using preselected and sample-derived cutoffs. Individual screeners demonstrated high specificity but low sensitivity, and each screener uniquely predicted validity status. Using conservative/preselected cutoffs, elevating ≥2 embedded SVTs significantly improved specificity to >99% with modest sensitivity (32%), while ≥3 elevations using liberal/sample-derived cutoffs resulted in 98% specificity but an improved sensitivity of 41%. Multiple elevations across embedded SVTs can identify noncredible responding/symptom endorsement on psychopathology screeners, thus signaling that more robust validity testing can be discontinued. However, given the lower sensitivity of this approach, these embedded SVTs may better rule in rather than rule out noncredible responding when elevated.Keywords
This publication has 53 references indexed in Scilit:
- Two Views of Invalid Response Set and Malingering Attributions in Forensic Assessment: Credibility and Non‐CredibilityBehavioral Sciences & the Law, 2025
- Seeing Clearly in the Twilight: The Clinical and Forensic Relevance of the Indeterminate/Borderline Range in Multivariate Models of Performance Validity AssessmentPsychological Injury and Law, 2024
- Review of Statistical and Methodological Issues in the Forensic Prediction of Malingering from Validity Tests: Part I: Statistical IssuesNeuropsychology Review, 2023
- Review of Statistical and Methodological Issues in the Forensic Prediction of Malingering from Validity Tests: Part II—Methodological IssuesNeuropsychology Review, 2023
- Symptom validity indices in the Posttraumatic Stress Disorder Checklist for DSM‐5Journal of Traumatic Stress, 2023
- Assessing Negative Response Bias Using Self-Report Measures: New Articles, New IssuesPsychological Injury and Law, 2022
- Assessing Negative Response Bias: a Review of the Noncredible Overreporting Scales of the MMPI-2-RF and MMPI-3Psychological Injury and Law, 2021
- The Self-Report Symptom InventoryPsychological Injury and Law, 2021
- The Posttraumatic Stress Disorder Checklist for DSM‐5 (PCL‐5): Development and Initial Psychometric EvaluationJournal of Traumatic Stress, 2015
- Distinguishing anxiety and depression in self‐report: purification of the beck anxiety inventory and beck depression inventory‐IIJournal of Clinical Psychology, 2010