From Assistance to Autonomy: Acceptability of Progressive Artificial Intelligence Integration in Facial Reconstructive Surgery—Protocol for Within-Subjects Vignette Experiment Among Romanian Adults
Authors:
- Valeria DinaVDValeria Dina
- Andrei-Paul TentAndrei-Paul Tent
- Andrei-Teodor MaghiarAMAndrei-Teodor Maghiar
- Ruxandra Florina BodogRBRuxandra Florina Bodog
- Titus-Andrei GrecuTGTitus-Andrei Grecu
- Octavian-Marius CrețuOCOctavian-Marius Crețu
- Laura MaghiarLaura Maghiar
- Florian BodogFBFlorian Bodog
- Georgiana Albina CăițăGCGeorgiana Albina Căiță
- Mircea Ioan ȘandorMȘMircea Ioan Șandor
- Ioan LascărILIoan Lascăr
Open Access
- 15 September 2026
- journal article
- research article
- Published by MDPI AG in Healthcare
- Vol. 14 (18) , 3030
Abstract
Artificial intelligence (AI) is entering surgical planning along a continuum that runs from imaging assistance to near-autonomous plan generation, and facial reconstructive surgery—where outcomes bear directly on identity and social functioning—is among the most sensitive settings for this transition. Existing acceptability research has largely compared AI-supported care with conventional care in binary designs, and Central and Eastern European populations remain underrepresented. This protocol describes a cross-sectional, within-subjects vignette experiment among Romanian adults recruited online (target N = 300 valid responses; minimum analyzable N = 140, raised by a pre-registered rule if the pilot’s inter-scenario correlation falls below the planning assumption). Each participant will read four hypothetical scenarios describing progressively autonomous AI involvement in facial reconstructive surgical planning: imaging assistance, decision support, outcome simulation, and autonomous planning. Participants are randomly allocated to one of the four sequences of a Williams balanced Latin-square design, so that the autonomy level is orthogonal to serial position and to first-order carry-over. After each scenario, they will rate acceptability, trust, and perceived risk (three seven-point Likert items each), responsibility attribution across four loci (surgeon, hospital, AI developer, unavoidable medical uncertainty), perceived AI control and perceived technical sophistication (manipulation checks), and scenario difficulty. Primary analyses are mixed repeated-measures ANOVAs with presentation sequence as a between-subjects factor, orthogonal polynomial (linear, quadratic, cubic) trend contrasts, and Holm-corrected pairwise comparisons, complemented by a position-adjusted linear mixed model; secondary analyses address responsibility migration and concentration, moderation by AI familiarity, and global implementation preferences. A pilot study (N = 50, allocated 1:1 to the ascending and descending sequences) will establish reliability, factor structure, comprehension, manipulation validity, and a first bound on order effects before pre-registration on the Open Science Framework and the start of data collection.Keywords
Funding Information
- University of Oradea, Romania
This publication has 75 references indexed in Scilit:
- Shall we call for a doctor? How to build trust toward AI in healthcare: Insights from a Polish cross-sectional preference studyHealth Policy, 2025
- Multinational Attitudes Toward AI in Health Care and Diagnostics Among Hospital PatientsJAMA Network Open, 2025
- Patient Perceptions of Artificial Intelligence in Hand Surgery: A Survey of 511 Patients Presenting to a Hand Surgery ClinicThe Journal of Hand Surgery, 2025
- World Medical Association Declaration of HelsinkiJAMA, 2025
- Public Attitudes Toward Notification of Use of Artificial Intelligence in Health CareJAMA Network Open, 2024
- Publication of Results of Registered Trials With Published Study Protocols, 2011-2022JAMA Network Open, 2024
- Responsibility Gaps and Black Box Healthcare AI: Shared Responsibilization as a SolutionDigital Society, 2023
- Automated segmentation of head CT scans for computer-assisted craniomaxillofacial surgery applying a hierarchical patch-based stack of convolutional neural networksInternational Journal of Computer Assisted Radiology and Surgery, 2022
- Perspectives of Patients About Artificial Intelligence in Health CareJAMA Network Open, 2022
- Diffused responsibility: attributions of responsibility in the use of AI-driven clinical decision support systemsAI and Ethics, 2022