Moratoria in International Politics: A Comparative Analysis of the Moratoria on Genetically Modified Products and Commercial Whaling
- 19 December 2011
- journal article
- Published by SAGE Publications in The British Journal of Politics and International Relations
- Vol. 14 (4) , 518-533
Abstract
Little research has been conducted into the role of moratoria in international politics despite their importance in many areas of policy-making. This article investigates that role by a comparative analysis of two of the most prominent moratoria in recent years: the moratorium on genetically modified (GM) products imposed by the European Union (EU) in 1999; and the moratorium on commercial whaling imposed by the International Whaling Commission (IWC) in 1982. The main finding of the study is that while the formal role of these moratoria was to postpone making a substantive decision until further scientific research had been carried out, in practice they served very different political purposes: the EU GM moratorium dampened down political heat while the EU was under pressure from member states regarding environmental issues and from the US regarding trade issues; whereas the IWC moratorium was a moral denunciation of killing whales. The wider implication of the analysis is that moratoria are complex phenomena, varied in their functions and effects, and they deserve to be studied more seriously.Keywords
This publication has 20 references indexed in Scilit:
- Contemporary initiatives on the future of the International Whaling CommissionMarine Policy, 2010
- The Hogarth initiative on the future of the International Whaling CommissionMarine Policy, 2010
- Normalization of the International Whaling CommissionMarine Policy, 2008
- Modernisation of the International Convention for the Regulation of WhalingMarine Policy, 2008
- Compromise in the IWC: Is it possible or desirable?Marine Policy, 2008
- The whaling issue: Conservation, confusion, and casuistryMarine Policy, 2007
- The so-called ‘moratorium’ on the licensing of new genetically modified (GM) products by the European Union 1998–2004: a study in ambiguityEnvironmental Politics, 2006
- Multiple analysis of the whaling issue: Understanding the dispute by a matrixMarine Policy, 2006
- Scientific uncertainty and the International Whaling Commission: an alternative perspective on the use of science in policy makingMarine Policy, 2004
- The whaling issueMarine Policy, 2000