Defending explicability as a principle for the ethics of artificial intelligence in medicine
Top Cited Papers
Open Access
- 29 August 2023
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Springer Nature in Medicine, Health Care and Philosophy
- Vol. 26 (4) , 615-623
Abstract
The difficulty of explaining the outputs of artificial intelligence (AI) models and what has led to them is a notorious ethical problem wherever these technologies are applied, including in the medical domain, and one that has no obvious solution. This paper examines the proposal, made by Luciano Floridi and colleagues, to include a new ‘principle of explicability’ alongside the traditional four principles of bioethics that make up the theory of ‘principlism’. It specifically responds to a recent set of criticisms that challenge the supposed need for such a principle to perform an enabling role in relation to the traditional four principles and therefore suggest that these four are sufficient without the addition of explicability. The paper challenges the critics’ premise that explicability cannot be an ethical principle like the classic four because it is explicitly subordinate to them. It argues instead that principlism in its original formulation locates the justification for ethical principles in a midlevel position such that they mediate between the most general moral norms and the contextual requirements of medicine. This conception of an ethical principle then provides a mold for an approach to explicability on which it functions as an enabling principle that unifies technical/epistemic demands on AI and the requirements of high-level ethical theories. The paper finishes by anticipating an objection that decision-making by clinicians and AI fall equally, but implausibly, under the principle of explicability’s scope, which it rejects on the grounds that human decisions, unlike AI’s, can be explained by their social environments.Keywords
Funding Information
- University of Oslo
This publication has 42 references indexed in Scilit:
- Different methods for ethical analysis in health technology assessment: An empirical studyInternational Journal of Technology Assessment in Health Care, 2011
- Bioethics, Raw and Cooked: Extraordinary Conflict and Everyday PracticeJournal of Health and Social Behavior, 2010
- Principlism and moral dilemmas: a new principleJournal of Medical Ethics, 2005
- Principlism and communitarianismJournal of Medical Ethics, 2003
- Ethics needs principles—four can encompass the rest—and respect for autonomy should be “first among equals”Journal of Medical Ethics, 2003
- Information EthicsPhilosophy in the Contemporary World, 2002
- Common Morality versus Specified Principlism: Reply to RichardsonThe Journal of Medicine and Philosophy: A Forum for Bioethics and Philosophy of Medicine, 2000
- Common Morality as an Alternative to PrinciplismKennedy Institute of Ethics Journal, 1995
- Principlism and Its Alleged CompetitorsKennedy Institute of Ethics Journal, 1995
- Rethinking Informed ConsentThe Yale Law Journal, 1994