Abstract
One of the hardiest discussion threads on the Internet newsgroup devoted to classical music has been a long-term attempt to answer the perennial question, ‘What’s the deepest piece of music?’1 Aside from a few jokers (La Mer?), most who tackle the question frame it in terms of ideal content, usually extra-musical. They provide lists of pieces that seem ‘profound’, that appear to deal with meaningful, spiritual, universal issues: Beethoven’s Ninth, Bach’s B minor Mass, Parsifal, Mahler and Bruckner symphonies. An issue that almost never seems to come up is abstract musical structure: the idea that a composition models in some purely formal way a bounded, multi-level, often hierarchical space which provides a sense of depth and complexity independent of any hermeneutic goal.