Physical restraintsversusseclusion room for management of people with acute aggression or agitation due to psychotic illness (TREC-SAVE): a randomized trial
Authors:
- TREC-SAVE Collaborative GroupTGTREC-SAVE Collaborative Group
- 12 March 2012
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in Psychological Medicine
- Vol. 42 (11) , 2265-2273
Abstract
Background: After de-escalation techniques have failed, restraints, seclusion and/or rapid tranquillization may be used for people whose aggression is due to psychosis. Most coercive acts of health care have not been evaluated in trials.Method: People admitted to the emergency room of Instituto Philippe Pinel, Rio de Janeiro, Brazil, whose aggression/agitation was thought due to psychosis and for whom staff were unsure if best to restrict using physical restraints or a seclusion room, were randomly allocated to one or the other and followed up to 14 days. The primary outcomes were ‘no need to change intervention early – within 1 h’ and ‘not restricted by 4 h’.Results: A total of 105 people were randomized. Two-thirds of the people secluded were able to be fully managed in this way. Even taking into account the move out of seclusion into restraints, this study provides evidence that embarking on the less restrictive care pathway (seclusion) does not increase overall time in restriction of some sort [not restricted by 4 h: relative risk 1.09, 95% confidence interval 0.75–1.58; mean time to release: restraints 337.6 (s.d.=298.2) min, seclusion room 316.3 (s.d.=264.5) min,p=0.48]. Participants tended to be more satisfied with their care in the seclusion group (17.0%v. 11.1%) but this did not reach conventional levels of statistical significance (p=0.42).Conclusions: This study should be replicated, but suggests that opting for the least restrictive option in circumstances where there is clinical doubt does not harm or prolong coercion.Keywords
This publication has 21 references indexed in Scilit:
- TREC-SAVE: a randomised trial comparing mechanical restraints with use of seclusion for aggressive or violent seriously mentally ill people: study protocol for a randomised controlled trialTrials, 2011
- Factors associated with the use of physical restraints for agitated patients in psychiatric emergency roomsGeneral Hospital Psychiatry, 2008
- A randomized clinical trial to compare the use of safety net enclosures with standard restraints in agitated hospitalized patientsJournal of Hospital Medicine, 2007
- Rapid tranquillisation in psychiatric emergency settings in India: pragmatic randomised controlled trial of intramuscular olanzapine versus intramuscular haloperidol plus promethazineBMJ, 2007
- Rapid tranquillisation in psychiatric emergency settings in Brazil: pragmatic randomised controlled trial of intramuscular haloperidol versus intramuscular haloperidol plus promethazineBMJ, 2007
- The Portuguese version of the Clinical Global Impression - Schizophrenia Scale: validation studyBrazilian Journal of Psychiatry, 2007
- No health without mental healthThe Lancet, 2007
- The use of seclusion in emergency medicineGeneral Hospital Psychiatry, 2005
- Deaths associated with restraint use in health and social care in the UK. The results of a preliminary surveyJournal of Psychiatric and Mental Health Nursing, 2003
- Characteristics of effective nursing interventions in the management of challenging behaviourJournal of Advanced Nursing, 1992