The "Two Presidencies" in Future Research: Moving Beyond Roll-Call Analysis
Authors:
- 1 September 1993
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Congress & the Presidency
- Vol. 20 (2) , 103-118
Abstract
The two presidencies literature ostensibly seeks to determine whether presidents exercise more power over foreign policy than over domestic policy. In a laudable effort to be rigorous, scholars have sought to answer the question by examining roll-call voting in Congress. Doing so, however, changes the question from the power of the president versus Congress to the success of the president in Congress. Because presidents act without the approval of Congress far more often on foreign policy than they do on domestic policy, the two questions are not identical. Even with the narrower question of presidential success in Congress, several methodological problems cast doubt on the validity of previous studies. Future research needs to confront the problems plaguing roll-call analysis, and it needs to revisit the original question of how presidential influence varies across policy domains.Keywords
This publication has 25 references indexed in Scilit:
- Foreign and Defense Policy in Congress: A Research Agenda for the 1990sLegislative Studies Quarterly, 1992
- Congressional Oversight of the Department of Defense: Reconsidering the Conventional WisdomArmed Forces & Society, 1990
- Are There Two Presidencies? Yes, But Only for RepublicansThe Journal of Politics, 1988
- Mobilizing Political Support For U.S. National SecurityArmed Forces & Society, 1987
- The Congressional Committee Intelligence System: Information, Oversight, and ChangeCongress & the Presidency, 1987
- Congressional Support for the President: The View from the Kennedy/Johnson White HouseThe Journal of Politics, 1986
- An Evaluation of CQ Presidential Support Scores: The Relationship between Presidential Election Results and Congressional Voting DecisionsAmerican Journal of Political Science, 1986
- Response to CriticsThe Journal of Politics, 1981
- Reassessing the Reassessment: Comment on Sigelman's Note on the "Two Presidencies" ThesisThe Journal of Politics, 1981
- The Making of International Agreements: a Reappraisal of Congressional InvolvementThe Journal of Politics, 1978