Potential Bias of Instrumental Variable Analyses for Observational Comparative Effectiveness Research
- 15 July 2014
- journal article
- review article
- Published by American College of Physicians in Annals of Internal Medicine
- Vol. 161 (2) , 131-138
Abstract
Instrumental variable analysis is an increasingly popular method in comparative effectiveness research (CER). In theory, the instrument controls for unobserved and observed patient characteristics that affect the outcome. However, the results of instrumental variable analyses in observational settings may be biased if the instrument and outcome are related through an unadjusted third variable: an "instrument-outcome confounder." The authors identified published CER studies that used instrumental variable analysis and searched the literature for potential confounders of the most common instrument-outcome pairs. Of the 187 studies identified, 114 used 1 or more of the 4 most common instrument categories: distance to facility, regional variation, facility variation, and physician variation. Of these, 65 used mortality as an outcome. Potential unadjusted instrument-outcome confounders were observed in all studies, including patient race, socioeconomic status, clinical risk factors, health status, and urban or rural residency; facility and procedure volume; and co-occurring treatments. Only 4 (6%) instrumental variable CER studies considered potential instrument-outcome confounders outside the study data. Many effect estimates may be biased by the failure to adjust for instrument-outcome confounding. The authors caution against overreliance on instrumental variable studies for CER.Keywords
This publication has 55 references indexed in Scilit:
- Geographic Variation in Diagnosis Frequency and Risk of Death Among Medicare BeneficiariesJAMA, 2011
- Comparative effectiveness research: Policy context, methods development and research infrastructureStatistics in Medicine, 2010
- Instrumental variable methods in comparative safety and effectiveness researchPharmacoepidemiology and Drug Safety, 2010
- Teaching Hospital Status and Operative Mortality in the United StatesArchives of Surgery, 2010
- Differences in Patient Survival After Acute Myocardial Infarction by Hospital Capability of Performing Percutaneous Coronary InterventionArchives of internal medicine (1960), 2010
- Influence of physician specialty on outcomes after acute ischemic strokeJournal of Hospital Medicine, 2008
- Comparing invasive and noninvasive management strategies for acute myocardial infarction using administrative databasesAmerican Heart Journal, 2008
- A review of instrumental variables estimation of treatment effects in the applied health sciencesHealth Services and Outcomes Research Methodology, 2007
- Surgeon and Hospital Characteristics as Predictors of Major Adverse Outcomes Following Colon Cancer SurgeryArchives of Surgery, 2007
- Does More Intensive Treatment of Acute Myocardial Infarction in the Elderly Reduce Mortality?JAMA, 1994