Economic Risk Modeling in Forestry Projects Using Harvesting and Transportation Cost Variables
Authors:
- Luis Carlos de FreitasLFLuis Carlos de Freitas
- Márcio Lopes da SilvaMSMárcio Lopes da Silva
- Francisco de Assis Costa FerreiraFFFrancisco de Assis Costa Ferreira
- Nilton Cesar FiedlerNFNilton Cesar Fiedler
- Cassio Furtado LimaCassio Furtado Lima
- Roldão Carlos Andrade LimaRLRoldão Carlos Andrade Lima
- Luciano José MinetteLMLuciano José Minette
- Leonardo França da SilvaLSLeonardo França da Silva
- Stanley SchettinoSSStanley Schettino
- Victor Crespo de OliveiraVictor Crespo de Oliveira
- Lucas Moraes Rufini de SouzaLSLucas Moraes Rufini de Souza
Open Access
Abstract
This study evaluated the economic viability and risk of a eucalyptus forestry project by integrating deterministic and probabilistic economic analyses. Operational costs for motor–manual harvesting, manual extraction and loading, and forest transportation were estimated using standard cost models, while silvicultural, road maintenance, and transportation costs were obtained from operational records. Economic viability was assessed using Net Present Value (NPV), Internal Rate of Return (IRR), Equivalent Annual Value (EAV), and Average Production Cost (APC). Economic risk was evaluated through Monte Carlo simulation (10,000 iterations), considering ±10% variation in interest rate, transportation distance, harvesting productivity, labor, fuel, lubricant, and road maintenance costs, followed by sensitivity and correlation analyses. The project was economically viable, presenting an NPV of USD 110.11 ha−1, an IRR of 8.0%, an EAV of USD 20.43 ha−1 year−1, and an APC of USD 29.11 m−3. Transportation distance showed a limited operational slack of only 10 km when land cost was considered, indicating that the project operates close to its economic limit. Monte Carlo simulation indicated an 11.5% probability of economic infeasibility, while interest rate, transportation distance, and manual loading cost exerted the greatest negative influence on NPV. The integrated deterministic and probabilistic approach enabled the identification of critical operational thresholds for transportation distance, timber price, wood productivity, and land cost under the evaluated conditions, providing practical decision-support parameters for transportation planning, cost management, and economic risk assessment in similar forestry projects.Keywords
Funding Information
- Conselho Nacional de Desenvolvimento Científico e Tecnológico (101806/2024-8)
This publication has 43 references indexed in Scilit:
- Wood flow management for supply and demand synchronization: A literature reviewForest Policy and Economics, 2026
- Sustainable forestry logistics: Using modified A-star algorithm for efficient timber transportation route optimizationForest Policy and Economics, 2025
- Fuel Consumption and CO2 Emissions in Fully Mechanized Cut-to-Length (CTL) Harvesting Operations of Industrial Roundwood: A ReviewCurrent Forestry Reports, 2024
- Forest Supply Chains During Digitalization: Current Implementations and Prospects in Near FutureCurrent Forestry Reports, 2024
- Aboveground biomass estimation in forests with random forest and Monte Carlo-based uncertainty analysisEcological Indicators, 2022
- Factors Affecting Operational Cost and Productivity of Ground-Based Timber Harvesting Machines: a Meta-analysisCurrent Forestry Reports, 2022
- The economic reality of the forest and fuel management deficit on a fire prone western US national forestJournal of Environmental Management, 2021
- Impact of forest harvest intensity and transportation distance on biomass delivered costs within sustainable forest management - A case study in southeastern CanadaJournal of Environmental Management, 2021
- Sugarcane hybrids with original low lignin contents and high field productivity are useful to reach high glucose yields from bagasseBiomass and Bioenergy, 2015
- Accounting for uncertainty in a forest sector model using Monte Carlo simulationForest Policy and Economics, 2010