In Praise of Skepticism
Author:
Top Cited Papers
- 22 September 2022
- book
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP)
Abstract
A culture of trust is usually claimed to have many public benefits, by lubricating markets, managing organizations, legitimating governments, and facilitating collective action. If so, any signs of eroding trust are, and should be, a matter of serious concern. But the broader perspective developed in this book recognizes that trust has two faces, not one. Confidence in anti-vax theories has weakened herd immunity. Faith in Q-Anon conspiracy theories triggered violent insurrection. Disasters flow from gullible beliefs in fake Covid-19 cures, Madoff pyramid schemes, Putin’s claim to denazify Ukraine, and the Big Lie denying President Biden’s legitimate election. Trustworthiness involves an informal social contract by which principals authorize agents to act on their behalf in the expectation that they will fulfill their responsibilities with competency, integrity, and impartiality, despite conditions of risk and uncertainty. Skeptical judgments reflect reasonably accurate and informed predictions about agents’ future actions based on their past performance and guardrails deterring dishonesty, mendacity, and corruption. We should trust but verify. Unfortunately, assessments are commonly flawed. Both cynical beliefs (underestimating performance) and credulous faith (overestimating performance) involve erroneous judgments reflecting cultural biases, poor cognitive skills, and information echo chambers. These conclusions draw on new evidence from the European Values Survey/World Values Survey conducted among over 650,000 respondents in more than 100 societies over four decades. In Praise of Skepticism warns that an excess of credulous trust poses serious and hitherto unrecognized risks in a world full of seductive demagogues playing on insecurities, lying swindlers exploiting greed, and silver-tongued conspiracy theorists manipulating the darkest fears.Keywords
This publication has 12 references indexed in Scilit:
- Dissecting the Causal Chain from Quality of Government to Political Support2017
- Economic Performance and Political Trust2017
- Trust and Corruption2017
- Measuring Trust2017
- The Dark Side of Trust2006
- THREE. Confidence in Public Institutions: Faith, Culture, or Performance?2000
- Political Performance and Institutional Trust1999
- The Economic Performance of Governments1999
- Mapping Political Support in the 1990s: A Global Analysis1999
- Confidence in Political and Private Institutions1998