Evaluation of Protocols Allowing Emergency Medical Technicians to Determine Need for Treatment and Transport
Authors:
- Terri SchmidtTSTerri Schmidt
- Dave FullerDFDave Fuller
- Kyran ColbryKCKyran Colbry
- 28 June 2000
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Wiley in Academic Emergency Medicine
- Vol. 7 (6) , 663-669
Abstract
Objective: To determine whether emergency medical technicians (EMTs) can safely apply protocols to assign transport options and to assess agreement between groups of providers on application of the protocols. Methods: Developed protocols categorized patients as: 1) needs ambulance; 2) go to the emergency department (ED) by alternative means; 3) contact primary care provider (PCP); or 4) treat and release. After education on the application of the protocols, first responders and ambulance EMTs categorized patients at the scene prior to transport but did not change current practice. Ambulance reports were reviewed using a predetermined list of critical events that signified the need for an ambulance. Results: The EMTs categorized 1,300 study patients as follows: 1,023 (79%) needed ambulance transport, 200 (15%) could go to the ED by alternative means, 63 (5%) could contact a PCP, 14 (1%) could be treated and released. Categorizations by a first responder and the transporting EMT were compared for 209 patients. Collapsing categories to “need ambulance/do not need ambulance” showed fair concordance (kappa = 0.51). Initially, 30 of 277 (11%) patients determined not to need an ambulance appeared to experience a critical event. After review, 23 patients had events that may not warrant advanced life support transport. Seven (3%) had critical events in the ambulance warranting ambulance transport. Most were miscategorized by the EMT. Overall sensitivity and specificity for identifying patients needing ambulance transport were 94.5% and 32.8%, respectively. Conclusions: From 3% to 11% of patients determined on scene not to need an ambulance had a critical event. Emergency medical services systems need to determine an acceptable rate of undertriage. Further study is needed to determine whether better adherence to the protocols might increase safety.Keywords
This publication has 18 references indexed in Scilit:
- The Problem of Ambulance Misuse: Whose Problem Is It, Anyway?Academic Emergency Medicine, 1999
- Appropriate emergency medical services transport.Academic Emergency Medicine, 1999
- Inappropriate Use of Emergency Medical Services Transport: Comparison of Provider and Patient PerspectivesAcademic Emergency Medicine, 1999
- The reliability of prehospital clinical evaluation for potential spinal injury is not affected by the mechanism of injuryPrehospital Emergency Care, 1999
- Ethics of Emergency Department Triage: SAEM Position StatementAcademic Emergency Medicine, 1995
- Patient-Initiated Refusals of Prehospital Care: Ambulance Call Report Documentation, Patient Outcome, and On-line Medical CommandPrehospital and Disaster Medicine, 1995
- The emergent problem of ambulance misuseAnnals of Emergency Medicine, 1993
- Triage of patients out of the emergency department: Three-year experienceThe American Journal of Emergency Medicine, 1992
- High agreement but low kappa: II. Resolving the paradoxesJournal of Clinical Epidemiology, 1990
- Is the emergency ambulance service abused?BMJ, 1980