Thought experiments: Review and recommendations
Open Access
- 8 August 2022
- journal article
- review article
- Published by Wiley in Journal of Organizational Behavior
- Vol. 44 (3) , 544-560
Abstract
Summary: Thought experiments have been used as an effective methodological approach to advance theory in numerous scientific fields. However, they are underutilized in organizational behavior (OB) and adjacent fields. Accordingly, we conducted a comprehensive and multidisciplinary literature review of thought experiments that entailed 174 sources in economics, psychology, marketing, medicine, sociology, finance, and other fields. We used insights from this literature review to define and describe the unique nature of thought experiments and offer a taxonomy of four main types based on a theory's development stage (i.e., early vs. late) and a study's theoretical goal (i.e., confirmation vs. disconfirmation). We also provide a decision‐making tree useful for evaluating whether conducting a thought experiment is beneficial for a particular research situation and which of the four types is most likely to produce a meaningful contribution. Then, we offer best‐practice recommendations for conducting thought experiments that address how to plan, execute, report results, and discuss implications. In addition, we demonstrate the potential of thought experiments by using the best‐practice recommendations to design and conduct a thought experiment in the domain of workplace allyship. Finally, we offer suggestions for future substantive research that would benefit from thought experiment methodology (i.e., diversity, equity, and inclusion; leadership; performance; selection and recruitment; teams; and turnover). Overall, our article offers a comprehensive review and recommendations that we hope will be a catalyst for using thought experiments to advance theory in OB and related fields.Keywords
This publication has 109 references indexed in Scilit:
- Thoughts on whether government should steer a tropical cyclone if it couldJournal of Risk Research, 2012
- More Than Just Novelty: Conceptual Blending and CausalityAcademy of Management Review, 2012
- Glocalizing Nonaka’s knowledge creation model: Issues and challengesManagement Learning, 2011
- Dynamics in Groups: Are We There Yet?Academy of Management Annals, 2011
- Power, Ethics, and the IRBQualitative Inquiry, 2007
- Designing Experiments That GeneralizeOrganizational Research Methods, 2007
- The design of simulation studies in medical statisticsStatistics in Medicine, 2006
- Setting up a real ‘Chinese Room’: an empirical replication of a famous thought experiment1Journal of Experimental & Theoretical Artificial Intelligence, 1999
- A Sceptical Argument concerning the Value of a Behavioural Solution for AIDSSouth African Journal of Psychology, 1993
- Thought experiments since the scientific revolutionInternational Studies in the Philosophy of Science, 1986