We examine the emerging phenomenon of "reaching for synthetic yield" through covered call option writing by investment companies, using return and holdings data (including short positions) from a comprehensive sample of all U.S. options-writing funds. Funds become more aggressive in synthesizing income when interest rates, term premiums, and default premiums are low. Investors reward high-yield funds with inflows, conditional on total performance, without distinguishing between asset-generated yield and yield manufactured through option writing. However, yield-manufacturing funds experience greater total return losses, particularly in bull markets. This widespread yield manufacturing activity suppresses option prices and short-term implied volatility.