Mitochondrial Versus Nuclear Gene Sequences in Deep-Level Mammalian Phylogeny Reconstruction
Authors:
- Mark S. SpringerMSMark S. Springer
- Ronald W. DeBryRDRonald W. DeBry
- Christophe DouadyCDChristophe Douady
- Ole MadsenOMOle Madsen
- Wilfried W. de JongWJWilfried W. de Jong
- Michael J. StanhopeMSMichael J. Stanhope
Open Access
- 1 February 2001
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Molecular Biology and Evolution
- Vol. 18 (2) , 132-143
Abstract
Both mitochondrial and nuclear gene sequences have been employed in efforts to reconstruct deep-level phylogenetic relationships. A fundamental question in molecular systematics concerns the efficacy of different types of sequences in recovering clades at different taxonomic levels. We compared the performance of four mitochondrial data sets (cytochrome b, cytochrome oxidase II, NADH dehydrogenase subunit I, 12S rRNA–tRNA–16S rRNA) and eight nuclear data sets (exonic regions of α-2B adrenergic receptor, aquaporin, β-casein, γ-fibrinogen, interphotoreceptor retinoid binding protein, κ-casein, protamine, von Willebrand Factor) in recovering deep-level mammalian clades. We employed parsimony and minimum-evolution with a variety of distance corrections for superimposed substitutions. In 32 different pairwise comparisons between these mitochondrial and nuclear data sets, we used the maximum set of overlapping taxa. In each case, the variable-length bootstrap was used to resample at the size of the smaller data set. The nuclear exons consistently performed better than mitochondrial protein and rRNA-tRNA coding genes on a per-residue basis in recovering benchmark clades. We also concatenated nuclear genes for overlapping taxa and made comparisons with concatenated mitochondrial protein-coding genes from complete mitochondrial genomes. The variable-length bootstrap was used to score the recovery of benchmark clades as a function of the number of resampled base pairs. In every case, the nuclear concatenations were more efficient than the mitochondrial concatenations in recovering benchmark clades. Among genes included in our study, the nuclear genes were much less affected by superimposed substitutions. Nuclear genes having appropriate rates of substitution should receive strong consideration in efforts to reconstruct deep-level phylogenetic relationships.Keywords
This publication has 56 references indexed in Scilit:
- The mitochondrial DNA molecule of the aardvark, Orycteropus afer, and the position of the Tubulidentata in the eutherian treeProceedings Of The Royal Society B-Biological Sciences, 1999
- Interordinal Mammalian Relationships: Evidence for Paenungulate Monophyly Is Provided by Complete Mitochondrial 12S rRNA SequencesMolecular Phylogenetics and Evolution, 1996
- Evidence on Mammalian Phylogeny from Sequences of Exon 28 of the von Willebrand Factor GeneMolecular Phylogenetics and Evolution, 1996
- Cytochrome b nucleotide sequences and the identification of five primary lineages of extant cetaceansMolecular Biology and Evolution, 1996
- Inferring Phylogenies from mtDNA Variation: Mitochondrial-Gene Trees Versus Nuclear-Gene TreesEvolution, 1995
- Phylogeny of the Pteropodidae (Mammalia, Chiroptera) Based on Dna Hybridization, With Evidence for Bat MonophylyAustralian Journal of Zoology, 1995
- CLUSTAL W: improving the sensitivity of progressive multiple sequence alignment through sequence weighting, position-specific gap penalties and weight matrix choiceNucleic Acids Research, 1994
- Is the guinea-pig a rodent?Nature, 1991
- DNA Hybridization, the Compression Effect, and the Radiation of Diprotodontian MarsupialsSystematic Zoology, 1991
- Nuclear and Mitochondrial DNA Comparisons Reveal Extreme Rate Variation in the Molecular ClockScience, 1986