Artificial Intelligence in Deliberation: The AI Penalty and the Emergence of a New Deliberative Divide
Preprint
Abstract
Digital deliberation has expanded democratic participation, yet challenges remain. This includes processing information at scale, moderating discussions, fact-checking, or attracting people to participate. Recent advances in artificial intelligence (AI) offer potential solutions, but public perceptions of AI's role in deliberation remain underexplored. Beyond efficiency, democratic deliberation is about voice and recognition. If AI is integrated into deliberation, public trust, acceptance, and willingness to participate may be affected. We conducted a preregistered survey experiment with a representative sample in Germany (n=1850) to examine how information about AI-enabled deliberation influences willingness to participate and perceptions of deliberative quality. Respondents were randomly assigned to treatments that provided them information about deliberative tasks facilitated by either AI or humans. Our findings reveal a significant AI-penalty. Participants were less willing to engage in AI-facilitated deliberation and rated its quality lower than human-led formats. These effects were moderated by individual predispositions. Perceptions of AI's societal benefits and anthropomorphization of AI showed positive interaction effects on people's interest to participate in AI-enabled deliberative formats and positive quality assessments, while AI risk assessments showed negative interactions with information about AI-enabled deliberation. These results suggest AI-enabled deliberation faces substantial public skepticism, potentially even introducing a new deliberative divide. Unlike traditional participation gaps based on education or demographics, this divide is shaped by attitudes toward AI. As democratic engagement increasingly moves online, ensuring AI's role in deliberation does not discourage participation or deepen inequalities will be a key challenge for future research and policy.Keywords
All Related Versions
This publication has 33 references indexed in Scilit:
- Deliberative Democracy for Diabolical Times2024
- Response to Camila Vergara’s Review of Open Democracy: Reinventing Popular Rule for the Twenty-First CenturyPerspectives on Politics, 2022
- Whose AI? How different publics think about AI and its social impactsComputers in Human Behavior, 2022
- Politics with the People2018
- Automatic Debate Text Summarization in Online Debate ForumProcedia Computer Science, 2017
- Acceptance of nuclear power: The Fukushima effectEnergy Policy, 2013
- Who Wants To Deliberate—And Why?American Political Science Review, 2010
- The Internet and Democratic Citizenship2009
- On seeing human: A three-factor theory of anthropomorphism.Psychological Review, 2007
- Multiple Imputation for Nonresponse in Surveys1987