Does the New Route Reach its Destination?

Authors:
  • TRTeresa Robertson
    Teresa Robertson
  • GFGraeme Forbes
    Graeme Forbes

Abstract
In ‘A New Route to the Necessity of Origin’, Guy Rohrbaugh and Louis deRossett argue for the Necessity of Origin in a way that they believe avoids use of any kind of transworld constitutional sufficiency principle. In this discussion, we respond that either their arguments do imply a sufficiency principle, or else they entirely fail to establish the Necessity of Origin.