On the potential value conflict between scientific knowledge production and fair recognition of authorship
Open Access
- 2 February 2026
- journal article
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Accountability in Research
- Vol. 33 (6) , 2623480
Abstract
The value of scientific knowledge and fairness in distribution of academic credit are core values in research publication. However, it is little discussed in the literature that these values may come into conflict, particularly in interdisciplinary research. The point of this paper is to acknowledge and describe the conflict and discuss potential solutions. We use collaborations between pre-clinical (laboratory) researchers and clinicians at hospitals as an exemplifying case. We conclude that, without changing the preconditions for the value conflict, there is no general solution involving systematically prioritizing one value over the other. However, a potential way out of the conflict would be a general shift from authorship to contributorship regarding evaluation of contributions, but required routines are presently not in place with most journals.Keywords
This publication has 23 references indexed in Scilit:
- Implementation, barriers, and improvement strategies for CRediT: A scoping reviewAccountability in Research, 2025
- Authorship and Citizen Science: Seven Heuristic RulesScience and Engineering Ethics, 2024
- Misuse of co-authorship in Medical PhD Theses in Scandinavia: A Questionnaire SurveyJournal of Academic Ethics, 2022
- Authorship and justice: Credit and responsibilityAccountability in Research, 2020
- Is authorship sufficient for today’s collaborative research? A call for contributor rolesAccountability in Research, 2020
- No more first authors, no more last authorsNature, 2018
- Responsibility for scientific misconduct in collaborative papersMedicine, Health Care and Philosophy, 2017
- A framework for addressing ethical issues in citizen scienceEnvironmental Science & Policy, 2015
- Scientific authorship and intellectual involvement in the research: Should they coincide?Medicine, Health Care and Philosophy, 2014
- Recognition, reward and responsibility: Why the authorship of scientific papers mattersMaturitas, 2009