Reply to Jansen and Gjerde's (2021) critique of the salmon louse infection model reported in Johnsen et al. (2021)
Open Access
- 25 November 2021
- journal article
- editorial
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in ICES Journal of Marine Science
- Vol. 78 (10) , 3852-3857
Abstract
To estimate salmon lice-induced mortality of wild salmon post-smolts, a model system was developed by Johnsen et al. to support management strategies. To ensure realistic model estimates, lice-infestation values from the model were calibrated against empirical observations on wild post-smolts captured by trawling. These fish were genetically assigned to their rivers of origin. A critique by Jansen and Gjerde claims that the model developed by Johnsen et al. systematically overestimates lice induced mortality of post-smolts. Here, we illustrate how the analysis performed by Jansen and Gjerde is based upon two datasets that mismatch temporally and spatially. In addition, their analysis does not take uneven catch between the rivers into account. Due to this, we argue that the analysis in the criticism is not well founded. We also take the opportunity to present in more detail the observational dataset available for the model calibration, its limitations and the potential impacts on the model estimates. Additional validation with new data demonstrates that the model does not provide systematically biased results. Finally, we argue that the discrepancy between the modelled and observed lice levels in our system is not evidence of its shortcomings, but rather, represents an example of how model estimates can provide valuable supplementary information to empirical observations.Keywords
This publication has 17 references indexed in Scilit:
- Inferring Atlantic salmon post-smolt migration patterns using genetic assignmentRoyal Society Open Science, 2019
- The major threats to Atlantic salmon in NorwayICES Journal of Marine Science, 2017
- Estimating the temporal overlap between post-smolt migration of Atlantic salmon and salmon lice infestation pressure from fish farmsAquaculture Environment Interactions, 2016
- Diel migration pattern of Atlantic salmon (Salmo salar) and sea trout (Salmo trutta) smolts: an assessment of environmental cuesEcology of Freshwater Fish, 2016
- Evidence of salmon lice-induced mortality of anadromous brown trout (Salmo trutta) in the Hardangerfjord, NorwayMarine Biology Research, 2013
- Basin‐scale phenology and effects of climate variability on global timing of initial seaward migration of Atlantic salmon (Salmo salar)Global Change Biology, 2013
- Performance of farmed, hybrid, and wild Atlantic salmon (Salmo salar) families in a natural river environmentCanadian Journal of Fisheries and Aquatic Sciences, 2012
- Synchrony in the downstream migration of smolts and upstream migration of adult Atlantic salmon in the subarctic River UtsjokiJournal of Fish Biology, 2007
- Geographical differences in marine feeding of Atlantic salmon post‐smolts in Norwegian fjordsJournal of Fish Biology, 2004
- Laboratory and field investigations of salmon lice [Lepeophtheirus salmonis (Krøyer)] infestation on Atlantic salmon (Salmo salar L.) post-smoltsAquaculture Research, 2000