Toxicity Testing of Fifteen Non-Crop Plant Species with Six Herbicides in a Greenhouse Experiment: Implications for Risk Assessment
- 1 May 2004
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Springer Nature in Ecotoxicology
- Vol. 13 (4) , 349-369
Abstract
Estimation of risk to plants not targeted by herbicides when used in agricultural or forestry situations requires appropriate data on multiple species. Currently, many questions remain unresolved as to the adequate type and number of species to be tested. This paper presents the result of a unique greenhouse experiment where testing was performed with 15 non-crop plant species sprayed with 6 herbicides. The herbicides were chosen because of their different modes of action and because they are widely used in several countries. The plants favoured were species commonly found in field margins of Europe and/or North America. This dataset (called thereafter Danish/Canadian) was compared to the crop species that had been submitted to the US EPA for the same herbicides. In general, the selected plant species in the Danish/Canadian database were easy to grow and maintain in the greenhouse. The Danish/Canadian plants were overall more sensitive than the species tested in the US EPA data, yielding to a 5% protection threshold (HC5(50)) that was always more conservative. There was a large variability in plant responses among herbicides. Recommendations are provided on species that should and should not be used for risk assessment of non-target plants.Keywords
This publication has 45 references indexed in Scilit:
- Subtle Effects of Herbicide Use in the Context of Genetically Modified Crops: A Case Study with Glyphosate (Roundup®)Ecotoxicology, 2003
- Effects of Soil Copper on Black Bindweed ( Fallopia convolvulus ) in the Laboratory and in the FieldArchives of Environmental Contamination and Toxicology, 1998
- Effect of Herbicide Treatment on Host Plant Quality for a Leaf-Eating BeetlePesticide Science, 1996
- Potential Environmental Risks Associated with the New Sulfonylurea HerbicidesEnvironmental Science & Technology, 1994
- Confidence Limits for Hazardous Concentrations Based on Logistically Distributed NOEC Toxicity DataEcotoxicology and Environmental Safety, 1993
- Environmental Fate and Effects of Dicamba: A Canadian Perspective1993
- Ecotoxicological effects assessment: A comparison of several extrapolation proceduresEcotoxicology and Environmental Safety, 1991
- Effects of herbicide spray drift on selected species of nature conservation interest: The effects of plant age and surrounding vegetation structureEnvironmental Pollution, 1991
- Buffer zone widths for honeybees from ground and aerial spraying of insecticidesEnvironmental Pollution, 1990
- Assessment of the effects of herbicide spray drift on a range of plant species of conservation interestEnvironmental Pollution, 1989