Prospective Comparison of Live Evaluation and Video Review in the Evaluation of Operator Performance in a Pediatric Emergency Airway Simulation
Authors:
- Joseph B. HouseJHJoseph B. House
- Suzanne Dooley-HashSDSuzanne Dooley-Hash
- Terry KowalenkoTKTerry Kowalenko
- Athina SikavitsasASAthina Sikavitsas
- Desiree M. SeeyaveDSDesiree M. Seeyave
- John G. YoungerJYJohn G. Younger
- Stanley J. HamstraSHStanley J. Hamstra
- Michele M. NypaverMNMichele M. Nypaver
- 1 September 2012
- journal article
- Published by Journal of Graduate Medical Education in Journal of Graduate Medical Education
- Vol. 4 (3) , 312-316
Abstract
Introduction: Real-time assessment of operator performance during procedural simulation is a common practice that requires undivided attention by 1 or more reviewers, potentially over many repetitions of the same case. Objective: To determine whether reviewers display better interrater agreement of procedural competency when observing recorded, rather than live, performance; and to develop an assessment tool for pediatric rapid sequence intubation (pRSI). Methods: A framework of a previously established Objective Structured Assessment of Technical Skills (OSATS) tool was modified for pRSI. Emergency medicine residents (postgraduate year 1–4) were prospectively enrolled in a pRSI simulation scenario and evaluated by 2 live raters using the modified tool. Sessions were videotaped and reviewed by the same raters at least 4 months later. Raters were blinded to their initial rating. Interrater agreement was determined by using the Krippendorff generalized concordance method. Results: Overall interrater agreement for live review was 0.75 (95% confidence interval [CI], 0.72–0.78) and for video was 0.79 (95% CI, 0.73–0.82). Live review was significantly superior to video review in only 1 of the OSATS domains (Preparation) and was equivalent in the other domains. Intrarater agreement between the live and video evaluation was very good, greater than 0.75 for all raters, with a mean of 0.81 (95% CI, 0.76–0.85). Conclusion: The modified OSATS assessment tool demonstrated some evidence of validity in discriminating among levels of resident experience and high interreviewer reliability. With this tool, intrareviewer reliability was high between live and 4-months' delayed video review of the simulated procedure, which supports feasibility of delayed video review in resident assessment.Keywords
This publication has 18 references indexed in Scilit:
- Comparison of Checklist and Anchored Global Rating Instruments for Performance Rating of Simulated Pediatric EmergenciesSimulation in Healthcare: The Journal of the Society for Simulation in Healthcare, 2011
- Video-Based Assessment of Operative Competency in Endoscopic Sinus SurgeryAmerican Journal of Rhinology & Allergy, 2010
- Real‐Time Inter‐Rater Reliability of the Council of Emergency Medicine Residency Directors Standardized Direct Observation Assessment ToolAcademic Emergency Medicine, 2009
- Intermethod Reliability of Real‐time Versus Delayed Videotaped Evaluation of a High‐fidelity Medical Simulation Septic Shock ScenarioAcademic Emergency Medicine, 2009
- Simulated Pediatric Trauma Team ManagementPediatric Emergency Care, 2007
- Reliability of a Core Competency Checklist Assessment in the Emergency Department: The Standardized Direct Observation Assessment ToolAcademic Emergency Medicine, 2006
- Reliability of a Core Competency Checklist Assessment in the Emergency Department: The Standardized Direct Observation Assessment ToolAcademic Emergency Medicine, 2006
- Toward reliable operative assessment: the reliability and feasibility of videotaped assessment of laparoscopic technical skillsSurgical Endoscopy, 2004
- Length-based endotracheal tube and emergency equipment in pediatricsAnnals of Emergency Medicine, 1992
- Bootstrap Methods for Standard Errors, Confidence Intervals, and Other Measures of Statistical AccuracyStatistical Science, 1986