The ‘demented other’ or simply ‘a person’? Extending the philosophical discourse of Naue and Kroll through the situated self
- 9 September 2011
- journal article
- Published by Wiley in Nursing Philosophy
- Vol. 12 (4) , 282-292
Abstract
This article presents a critique of an article previously featured in Nursing Philosophy (10: 26-33) by Ursula Naue and Thilo Kroll, who suggested that people living with dementia are assigned a negative status upon receipt of a diagnosis, holding the identity of the 'demented other'. Specifically, in this critique, we suggest that unwitting use of the adjective 'demented' to define a person living with the condition is ill-informed and runs a risk of defining people through negative (self-)attributes, which has a deleterious impact upon that person's social and relational personae. Moreover, use of the locution 'demented' reinforces a divide between the 'demented' (them) and the 'healthy others' (us). Social constructionist theory, malignant positioning and viewing people with dementia as semiotic subjects are the philosophical pillars through which we construct the main arguments of the critique. The article concludes with the voice of one of the authors, a younger person with dementia, asking for language in dementia care to be carefully reconsidered and reframed and for the recognition of the diagnosed person's agency in the conduct of their day-to-day lives.Keywords
This publication has 17 references indexed in Scilit:
- Learning lessons: how I live with my Alzheimer's diseaseThe Journal of Mental Health Training, Education and Practice, 2010
- Abusive Interactions: Research in Locked Wards for People with DementiaSocial Policy and Society, 2010
- Sharing stories: a meta-ethnographic analysis of 12 autobiographies written by people with dementia between 1989 and 2007Ageing and Society, 2009
- ‘The demented other’: identity and difference in dementiaNursing Philosophy, 2008
- Meaningful social interactions between older people in institutional care settingsAgeing and Society, 2003
- Views of the person with dementiaJournal of Medical Ethics, 2001
- What's in a word: The distancing function of language in medicineJournal of Medical Humanities, 1992
- The Discursive Production of SelvesTheory & Psychology, 1991
- On Being Sane in Insane PlacesScience, 1973
- Psychosocial Aspects of DiseaseAnnals of Internal Medicine, 1969