Non-linear Mendelian randomization: detection of biases using negative controls with a focus on BMI, Vitamin D and LDL cholesterol
Top Cited Papers
Open Access
- 25 May 2024
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Springer Nature in European Journal of Epidemiology
- Vol. 39 (5) , 451-465
Abstract
Mendelian randomisation (MR) is an established technique in epidemiological investigation, using the principle of random allocation of genetic variants at conception to estimate the causal linear effect of an exposure on an outcome. Extensions to this technique include non-linear approaches that allow for differential effects of the exposure on the outcome depending on the level of the exposure. A widely used non-linear method is the residual approach, which estimates the causal effect within different strata of the non-genetically predicted exposure (i.e. the “residual” exposure). These “local” causal estimates are then used to make inferences about non-linear effects. Recent work has identified that this method can lead to estimates that are seriously biased, and a new method—the doubly-ranked method—has been introduced as a possibly more robust approach. In this paper, we perform negative control outcome analyses in the MR context. These are analyses with outcomes onto which the exposure should have no predicted causal effect. Using both methods we find clearly biased estimates in certain situations. We additionally examined a situation for which there are robust randomised controlled trial estimates of effects—that of low-density lipoprotein cholesterol (LDL-C) reduction onto myocardial infarction, where randomised trials have provided strong evidence of the shape of the relationship. The doubly-ranked method did not identify the same shape as the trial data, and for LDL-C and other lipids they generated some highly implausible findings. Therefore, we suggest there should be extensive simulation and empirical methodological examination of performance of both methods for NLMR under different conditions before further use of these methods. In the interim, use of NLMR methods needs justification, and a number of sanity checks (such as analysis of negative and positive control outcomes, sensitivity analyses excluding removal of strata at the extremes of the distribution, examination of biological plausibility and triangulation of results) should be performed.Keywords
All Related Versions
Funding Information
- Wellcome Trust (222894/Z/21/Z)
- Medical Research Council (MC_UU_00011/1)
This publication has 49 references indexed in Scilit:
- Dose-Response Associations of Lipid Traits With Coronary Artery Disease and MortalityJAMA Network Open, 2024
- Challenges in undertaking nonlinear Mendelian randomizationObesity, 2023
- Triglyceride content increases while cholesterol content decreases in HDL and LDL+IDL fractions following normal meals: The Copenhagen General Population Study of 25,656 individualsAtherosclerosis, 2023
- Polynomial Mendelian randomization reveals non-linear causal effects for obesity-related traitsHuman Genetics and Genomics Advances, 2022
- RETRACTED: Estimating dose-response relationships for vitamin D with coronary heart disease, stroke, and all-cause mortality: observational and Mendelian randomisation analysesThe Lancet Diabetes & Endocrinology, 2021
- Association Between Baseline LDL-C Level and Total and Cardiovascular Mortality After LDL-C LoweringJAMA, 2018
- Semiparametric methods for estimation of a nonlinear exposure‐outcome relationship using instrumental variables with application to Mendelian randomizationGenetic Epidemiology, 2017
- Efficacy and safety of more intensive lowering of LDL cholesterol: a meta-analysis of data from 170 000 participants in 26 randomised trialsThe Lancet, 2010
- Common genetic determinants of vitamin D insufficiency: a genome-wide association studyThe Lancet, 2010
- How independent are “independent” effects? relative risk estimation when correlated exposures are measured impreciselyJournal of Clinical Epidemiology, 1991