Freedom Restrictive Coercive Measures in Forensic Psychiatry
Authors:
Open Access
- 5 March 2020
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Frontiers Media SA in Frontiers in Psychiatry
- Vol. 11, 146
Abstract
Background: In Germany, people suffering from severe mental illness who have committed serious offenses and have considerably reduced or suspended criminal responsibility can be detained and treated in forensic psychiatric hospitals. In the German federal state of Baden-Wuerttemberg, all psychiatric hospitals including forensic psychiatric hospitals are obliged to record data on every coercive intervention and to submit them to a central registry. The objective of this study was to determine key measures for the use of seclusion and restraint and to compare them with data from the same registry on the use of coercion in general inpatient mental health care. Methods: Data on the main psychiatric diagnosis according to ICD-10, type and duration of each coercive measure and number of treated cases according to diagnoses, and cumulated number of days of treatment from all 8 forensic facilities in the state of Baden-Wuerttemberg covering a catchment area with about 11 million inhabitants were collected at the treated-case-level for 3 years. Results: 22.6% of the cases treated in 2017 in forensic psychiatric hospitals were subjected to seclusion, and 3.8% were subjected to mechanical restraint. The mean cumulated duration of seclusion episodes per affected case was 343.9 h and the mean cumulated duration of restraint episodes was 261.7 h. 13.2% of the treated cases were subjected to room confinement with a mean cumulated duration of 539.1 h per affected case. Involuntary medication was applied in 1.9% of the cases. In general psychiatry, 2.9% of the treated cases were subjected to seclusion, and 4.7% were subjected to mechanical restraint. The mean cumulated duration per affected case amounted to 32.2 h for seclusion episodes and to 37.6 h for restraint episodes. Involuntary medication was applied in 0.6% of cases. Conclusion: Compared to general psychiatry, mechanical restraint is used in forensic psychiatry substantially less frequently and seclusion substantially more frequently. Room confinement is used only in forensic psychiatric hospitals. Use of involuntary medication is rare. On the one hand, recorded involuntary medication comprises only clear actions against the patient's expressed will as defined by law. Psychological pressure to take medication to avoid other forms of coercion and to achieve higher levels of freedom within the facility is not recorded. On the other hand, the low numbers of clear involuntary medication probably reflect the high legal threshold for such interventions, and, consequently, efforts by staff to motivate voluntary acceptance. The long duration of freedom-restricting coercive measures in forensic psychiatry probably reflects the selection of patients at high risk of violence.Keywords
This publication has 16 references indexed in Scilit:
- Seclusion Reduction in Dutch Mental Health Care: Did Hospitals Meet Goals?Psychiatric Services, 2016
- Zwangsmaßnahmen in der forensischen PsychiatrieDer Nervenarzt, 2015
- The Use of Coercive Interventions in Mental Health Care in Germany and the Netherlands. A Comparison of the Developments in Two Neighboring CountriesFrontiers in Public Health, 2014
- Langzeittendenzen in der Anwendung von Fixierungen und Isolierungen in fünf psychiatrischen KlinikenPsychiatrische Praxis, 2014
- Auswirkungen der vorübergehend fehlenden Rechtsgrundlage für Zwangsbehandlungen auf die Häufigkeit aggressiver Vorfälle und freiheitseinschränkender mechanischer Zwangsmaßnahmen bei Patienten mit psychotischen StörungenPsychiatrische Praxis, 2014
- Cluster-Randomized Controlled Trial of Reducing Seclusion and Restraint in Secured Care of Men With SchizophreniaPsychiatric Services, 2013
- Reducing seclusion through involuntary medication: A randomized clinical trialPsychiatry Research, 2013
- Patients’ Preference and Experiences of Forced Medication and SeclusionPsychiatric Quarterly, 2011
- Patients' Preferences for Seclusion or Forced Medication in Acute Psychiatric Emergency in the NetherlandsPsychiatric Services, 2008
- Diagnosis-related frequency of compulsory measures in 10 German psychiatric hospitals and correlates with hospital characteristicsSocial Psychiatry and Psychiatric Epidemiology, 2006