Managing Technology Selection and Development Risk in Competitive Environments
- 1 July 2011
- journal article
- Published by SAGE Publications in Production and Operations Management
- Vol. 20 (4) , 541-555
Abstract
Managing development decisions for new products based on dynamically evolving technologies is a complex task, especially in highly competitive industries. Product managers often have to choose between introducing an incrementally better, safe new product early and a superior, yet highly risky, product later. Recommendations for managing such performance vs. time‐to‐market trade‐offs often ignore competitive reactions to development decisions. In this paper, we study how a firm could incorporate the presence of a strategic competitor in making technology selection and investment decisions regarding new products. We consider a model in which an innovating firm and its rival can introduce a new product immediately or pursue a more advanced product for later launch. Further, the firm can reduce the uncertainty surrounding product development by dedicating more resources; the effectiveness of this investment depends on the firm's innovative capacity. Our model generates two sets of insights. First, in highly competitive industries, firms can adopt different technologies and effectively use introduction timing to mitigate the effects of price competition. More importantly, the firm could strategically invest in the advanced product to influence its rival's technology choice. We characterize equilibrium development and investment decisions of the firms, and derive innovative capacity hurdles that govern a firm's choice between the risky and safe alternatives. The effects of development flexibility—where firms might have the option to revert to the safe product if the advanced product fails—are also considered.Keywords
This publication has 16 references indexed in Scilit:
- Competitive Product Introductions in Technologically Dynamic EnvironmentsSSRN Electronic Journal, 2007
- A Retrospective Look at Production and Operations Management Articles on New Product DevelopmentProduction and Operations Management, 2005
- Rush and Be Wrong or Wait and Be Late? A Model of Information in Collaborative ProcessesProduction and Operations Management, 2005
- Up or Out—or Stay Put? Product Positioning in an Evolving Technology EnvironmentProduction and Operations Management, 2005
- New-Product Strategy and Industry ClockspeedManagement Science, 2004
- OPTIMAL PROJECT SEQUENCING WITH RECOURSE AT A SCARCE RESOURCEProduction and Operations Management, 2003
- Dynamic Portfolio Selection of NPD Programs Using Marginal ReturnsManagement Science, 2002
- Managing Development Risk in Product Design ProcessesOperations Research, 1999
- Speed-to-market and new product performance trade-offsJournal of Product Innovation Management, 1997
- Speed‐to‐Market and New Product Performance Trade‐offsJournal of Product Innovation Management, 1997