Potential toxicity benefit and inter-fraction robustness of proton arc therapy compared to IMPT and VMAT for nasopharyngeal cancer patients
Open Access
- 7 May 2025
- journal article
- Published by IOP Publishing in Physics in Medicine & Biology
- Vol. 70 (10) , 105007
Abstract
Objective. Radiotherapy in nasopharyngeal cancer (NPC) patients presents challenges due to proximity of many anatomical structures to the target volume. Furthermore, inter-fractional changes must be considered to assure target coverage. Proton arc therapy (PAT) potentially reduces healthy tissue dose compared to IMPT and VMAT. The impact of PAT on dose to organs-at-risk (OARs), predicted acute-and late radiation toxicities and robust target coverage to inter-fraction changes in NPC patients were investigated. Approach. Robustly optimized PAT plans were compared to clinical VMAT and IMPT plans for 10 NPC patients treated with 70.00 Gy to the primary target (CTV 7000) and 54.25 Gy to the prophylactic lymph nodal area (CTV 5425). Integral body dose and mean and max in 0.03cc dose (D mean and max D0.03cc) in OARs were compared. Normal tissue complication probability (NTCP) values for 22 acute and late radiation-induced toxicities were evaluated. A PAT ‘base approach’ and nine PAT planning approaches to improve PAT inter-fraction robust target coverage were investigated. Target coverage was evaluated on in total 54 weekly repeated CT images (rCTs). Main results. PAT integral dose reduced by on average 55% and 15% compared with clinical VMAT and IMPT, respectively. Compared to IMPT, average D mean and max D0.03cc were significantly reduced in all evaluated neurological structures. Compared to IMPT, in the PAT plans D mean was reduced most in the arytenoids, PCM medius and brainstem by on average 8.0 Gy, 6.4 Gy and 6.1 Gy, respectively and all evaluated NTCP’s for both acute and late timepoint were significantly reduced. Compared with IMPT, PAT base approach target coverage on rCTs was worse. Approaches to improve PAT inter-fraction target coverage were successful, while maintaining the reduction in NTCP compared to IMPT. Significance. Compared to IMPT and VMAT, PAT reduces healthy tissue dose and subsequent estimated toxicity risks in NPC patients. PAT planning approaches to improve inter-fraction robustness were employed successfully, while NTCP benefits of PAT were maintained.Keywords
Funding Information
- IBA Ltd (PPP-19-042)
- University Medical Center Groningen (UMCG), Groningen, The Netherlands (PPP-19-042)
- Ministry of Economic Affairs (PPP-19-042)
This publication has 37 references indexed in Scilit:
- Partitioning of discrete proton arcs into interlaced subplans can bring proton arc advances to existing proton facilitiesMedical Physics, 2023
- Spot scanning proton arc therapy reduces toxicity in oropharyngeal cancer patientsMedical Physics, 2023
- Proton beam radiation therapy treatment for head and neck cancerPrecision Radiation Oncology, 2021
- Clinical validation of a GPU-based Monte Carlo dose engine of a commercial treatment planning system for pencil beam scanning proton therapyPhysica Medica, 2021
- Spot-Scanning Proton Arc (SPArc) Therapy: The First Robust and Delivery-Efficient Spot-Scanning Proton Arc TherapyInternational Journal of Radiation Oncology - Biology - Physics (IJROBP), 2016
- Epidemiology and Inequality in the Incidence and Mortality of Nasopharynx Cancer in AsiaOsong Public Health and Research Perspectives, 2016
- Evaluation of Robustness to Setup and Range Uncertainties for Head and Neck Patients Treated With Pencil Beam Scanning Proton TherapyInternational Journal of Radiation Oncology - Biology - Physics (IJROBP), 2016
- Dual Arc Volumetric-modulated Arc Radiotherapy (VMAT) of Nasopharyngeal Carcinomas: A Simultaneous Integrated Boost Treatment Plan Comparison with Intensity-modulated Radiotherapies and Single Arc VMATClinical Oncology, 2012
- Impact of CT Metal Artifacts on Proton Radiotherapy Treatment PlanningInternational Journal of Radiation Oncology - Biology - Physics (IJROBP), 2010
- Range, Setup and Dose Calculation Errors in IMPT and Their Interrelation2009