Historical Models and Serial Sources
Open Access
- 29 June 2019
- journal article
- Published by Ghent University in Journal of European Periodical Studies
- Vol. 4 (1) , 8-18
Abstract
Serial sources such as records, registers, and inventories are the ‘classic’ sources for quantitative history. Unstructured, narrative texts such as newspaper articles or reports were out of reach for historical analyses, both for practical reasons — availability, time needed for manual processing — and for methodological reasons: manual coding of texts is notoriously difficult and hampered by low inter-coder reliability. The recent availability of large amounts of digitized sources allows for the application of natural language processing, which has the potential to overcome these problems. However, the automatic evaluation of large amounts of texts — and historical texts in particular — for historical research also brings new challenges. First of all, it requires a source criticism that goes beyond the individual source and also considers the corpus as a whole. It is a well-known problem in corpus linguistics to determine the ‘balancedness’ of a corpus, but when analyzing the content of texts rather than ‘just’ the language, determining the ‘meaningfulness’ of a corpus is even more important. Second, automatic analyses require operationalizable descriptions of the information you are looking for. Third, automatically produced results require interpretation, in particular, when — as in history — the ultimate research question is qualitative, not quantitative. This, finally, poses the question, whether the insights gained could inform formal, i.e., machine-processable, models, which could serve as foundation and stepping stones for further research.Keywords
This publication has 4 references indexed in Scilit:
- Natural Language Processing for Historical TextsSynthesis Lectures on Human Language Technologies, 2012
- Quantitative Analysis of Culture Using Millions of Digitized BooksScience, 2011
- Modeling: A Study in Words and Meanings2004
- Methodological Issues Regarding Corpus-based Analyses of Linguistic VariationLiterary and Linguistic Computing, 1990