This study examines the impact of foreign institutional investors (FIIs) on investee firms’ environmental disclosures. In line with prior research, we find that on aggregate the presence of FIIs is generally associated with improved environmental disclosure. However, this effect masks important differences across investor types. Using data from listed firms in India, we examine three environmentally aligned attributes: being a PRI signatory, being an independent investor, and originating from a country with high environmental social norms. If FIIs are classified according to only one of these characteristics, we find a positive effect on disclosure. However, a deeper analysis shows that the impact is largely driven by FIIs with all three attributes. With the exception of the Big Three, FIIs that lack even one of these characteristics do not significantly affect environmental disclosures. Despite holding relatively small ownership stakes, these FIIs appear to exert a disproportionate influence on environmental disclosure practices. Channel analysis shows the effect is due to monitoring rather than these firms selecting companies that already have good environmental disclosures.