The 'expert' in problem-based and case-based learning: necessary or not?
Authors:
- Phillipa Jane HayPHPhillipa Jane Hay
- Mary KatsikitisMKMary Katsikitis
- 4 January 2001
- journal article
- clinical trial
- Published by Wiley in Medical Education
- Vol. 35 (1) , 22-26
Abstract
Problem-based learning (PBL) and other small-group teaching methods which incorporate principles of adult learning, are exciting innovations in medical education. In the application of these methods to medical curricula many schools have introduced non-expert tutors. However, research evaluating the effectiveness of non-expert lead teaching has been inconclusive. The present study aim was to compare the outcome of teaching in small groups facilitated by either an 'expert' or a 'non-expert' tutor, in a single topic area. Fourth-year medical students were allocated randomly to teaching of eating disorders either by a non-expert or an expert tutor. Outcomes were evaluated by (i) a knowledge test, and (ii) self-report ratings by tutors and students of their learning methods and other qualities. The study found that while the non-expert tutor was rated more highly for her group management skills, and she also rated her students more highly in the area of oral communication, students who were taught by the expert scored higher in the end-of-course test in the topic area. The findings suggest that caution should be exercised, and the need for more research before widespread adoption of teaching by non-expert tutors.Keywords
This publication has 13 references indexed in Scilit:
- Effects of tutor expertise on student performance in relation to prior knowledge and level of curricular structureAcademic Medicine, 1996
- A novel extension of problem‐based learning: problem‐based lecture presentation by studentsMedical Education, 1995
- Shifting students and faculty to a PBL curriculumAcademic Medicine, 1995
- Resolving inconsistencies in tutor expertise researchAcademic Medicine, 1994
- Influence of a highly focused case on the effect of small-group facilitatorsʼ content expertise on studentsʼ learning and satisfactionAcademic Medicine, 1994
- Influence of tutorsʼ subject-matter expertise on student effort and achievement in problem-based learningAcademic Medicine, 1993
- Foundations of problem‐based learning: some explanatory notesMedical Education, 1993
- Effects of tutors with case expertise on problem-based learning issuesAcademic Medicine, 1992
- Effects of expert and non-expert facilitators on the small-group process and on student performanceAcademic Medicine, 1992
- Medical Education in the United States and CanadaScience, 1910