Towards Integration of Security and Safety Measures for Critical Infrastructures Based on Bayesian Networks and Graph Theory: A Systematic Literature Review
Open Access
Abstract
In recent times, security and safety are, at least, conducted in safety-sensitive or critical sectors. Nevertheless, both processes do not commonly analyze the impact of security risks on safety. Several scholars are focused on integrating safety and security risk assessments, using different methodologies and tools in critical infrastructures (CIs). Bayesian networks (BN) and graph theory (GT) have received much attention from academia and industries to incorporate security and safety features for different CI applications. Hence, this study aims to conduct a systematic literature review (SLR) for co-engineering safety and security using BN or GT. In this SLR, the preferred reporting items for systematic reviews and meta-analyses recommendations (PRISMA) are followed. Initially, 2295 records (acquired between 2011 and 2020) were identified for screening purposes. Later on, 240 articles were processed to check eligibility criteria. Overall, this study includes 64 papers, after examining the pre-defined criteria and guidelines. Further, the included studies were compared, regarding the number of required nodes for system development, applied data sources, research outcomes, threat actors, performance verification mechanisms, implementation scenarios, applicability and functionality, application sectors, advantages, and disadvantages for combining safety, and security measures, based on GT and BN. The findings of this SLR suggest that BN and GT are used widely for risk and failure management in several domains. The highly focused sectors include studies of the maritime industry (14%), vehicle transportation (13%), railway (13%), nuclear (6%), chemical industry (6%), gas and pipelines (5%), smart grid (5%), network security (5%), air transportation (3%), public sector (3%), and cyber-physical systems (3%). It is also observed that 80% of the included studies use BN models to incorporate safety and security concerns, whereas 15% and 5% for GT approaches and joint GT and BN methodologies, respectively. Additionally, 31% of identified studies verified that the developed approaches used real-time implementation, whereas simulation or preliminary analysis were presented for the remaining methods. Finally, the main research limitations, concluding remarks and future research directions, are presentedKeywords
This publication has 99 references indexed in Scilit:
- Extending Petri net to reduce control strategies of railway interlocking systemApplied Mathematical Modelling, 2014
- Fault Tree Analysis for Safety/Security Verification in Aviation SoftwareElectronics, 2013
- V&V-based remaining fault estimation model for safety–critical software of a nuclear power plantAnnals of Nuclear Energy, 2013
- How to commercialize reliable capacities on a complex transmission network?Journal of Natural Gas Science and Engineering, 2011
- Specification of Supervisory Control Systems for Ventricular Assist DevicesArtificial Organs, 2011
- An approach for modelling interdependent infrastructures in the context of vulnerability analysisReliability Engineering & System Safety, 2010
- Learning Bayesian network parameters under incomplete data with domain knowledgePattern Recognition, 2009
- Integrating cyber attacks within fault treesReliability Engineering & System Safety, 2009
- Learning Bayesian networks: The combination of knowledge and statistical dataMachine Learning, 1995
- A Bayesian method for the induction of probabilistic networks from dataMachine Learning, 1992