Comparative Evaluation of the Performance of ZigBee and LoRa Wireless Networks in Building Environment
Open Access
- 31 October 2022
- journal article
- research article
- Published by MDPI AG in Electronics
- Vol. 11 (21) , 3560
Abstract
ZigBee and LoRa are communication technologies widely used in the application of the Internet of things (IoT), especially in the field of smart building environmental monitoring. The main purpose of this study is to compare and analyze the transmission performance of ZigBee and LoRa wireless communication networks in the building. Through two indicators of packet loss rate (PLR) and round-trip time (RTT), this paper discusses in detail the transmission performance of ZigBee and LoRa technologies in whole buildings under the same working conditions. We set up three experimental scenarios of line-of-sight, horizontal and vertical to evaluate the communication performance of these two networks by changing the baud rate and packet length, and cost and power consumption were considered. Experiments have shown that LoRa networks outperform ZigBee networks in most cases and are the best choice for building communication networks. The experimental results provide basic data support and engineering reference for the application of these two technologies in buildings, especially for the deployment of communication networks throughout buildings. The innovation and contribution of this paper are to discuss the effect of packet length, baud rate, distance, and different locations within a building on the performance of ZigBee and LoRa transmissions, using RTT and PLR as metrics through three experimental scenarios.Keywords
Funding Information
- National Natural Science Foundation of China (52178066, 61803067, 52008073, 2019-ZD-0174)
- NSFC Guidance Program Projects of Liaoning Province (52178066, 61803067, 52008073, 2019-ZD-0174)
This publication has 39 references indexed in Scilit:
- Building automation systems: Concepts and technology reviewComputer Standards & Interfaces, 2016
- Personal Environmental Monitoring System and network platform2015
- Review of communication technologies for smart homes/building applications2015
- A Cost-effective Wireless Sensor Network System for Indoor Air Quality Monitoring ApplicationsProcedia Computer Science, 2014
- Wireless Sensor Network for multi-storey building: Design and implementation2013
- Smart meters for power grid: Challenges, issues, advantages and statusRenewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews, 2011
- Passive control methods of Kerala traditional architecture for a comfortable indoor environment: Comparative investigation during various periods of rainy seasonBuilding and Environment, 2010
- Wireless sensor network performance metrics for building applicationsEnergy and Buildings, 2010
- Effects of thermal activated building systems in schools on thermal comfort in winterBuilding and Environment, 2009
- Implementation of an integrated indoor environment and energy management systemEnergy and Buildings, 2005