Drawing on memory: A meta‐analytic review
Open Access
- 18 April 2024
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Wiley in Journal of Investigative Psychology and Offender Profiling
- Vol. 21 (3)
Abstract
Drawing is commonly used to facilitate event recall in eyewitness and therapeutic settings. Building on Derksen and Connolly’s (2022) review, we meta‐analytically examined how drawing affects memory relative to purely verbal methods of communication (e.g. ‘talk only’ interviews). Database searches identified 36 randomised controlled trials of the effect of drawing‐based interventions on event memory (N = 2013). Our memory outcome measures were amount and accuracy of information reported, errors and confabulations. Random‐effects analysis indicated drawing was favoured relative to verbal controls across these four outcomes. Drawing enhanced the amount (g = 0.63, p < .001) and accuracy (g = 0.29, p = .014) of information reported, but did not reduce errors (g = 0.05, p = .633) or confabulations (g = 0.22, p = .488) relative to control. The memory benefits of drawing were not moderated by age (children vs. adults), event type (autobiographical vs. live/staged vs. video), control type (visual‐active vs. verbal‐only) or task timing (immediate vs. delay). Two potential moderators could not be analysed due to the paucity of studies: event focus (trauma‐related vs. non‐trauma‐related) and drawing focus (event‐focused vs. non‐event‐focused). Our meta‐analysis indicates that drawing is a valuable facilitator of event recall relative to traditional methods of communication. However, our review also highlights the need for more trauma‐specific studies. We address and offer practical recommendations for future studies to address potential risks that may result from using drawing in applied settings.Keywords
This publication has 54 references indexed in Scilit:
- Measuring the effectiveness of the sketch procedure for recalling details of a live interactive eventApplied Cognitive Psychology, 2018
- Facilitating memory‐based lie detection in immediate and delayed interviewing: The role of mnemonicsApplied Cognitive Psychology, 2018
- Getting the Picture: Effects of Sketch Plans and Photographs on Children's, Adolescents' and Adults' Eyewitness RecallApplied Cognitive Psychology, 2015
- Evaluating the Effectiveness of the Self‐Administered Interview© for Witnesses with Autism Spectrum DisorderApplied Cognitive Psychology, 2014
- The Clinical and Forensic Value of Information that Children Report While DrawingApplied Cognitive Psychology, 2013
- Do Non‐Verbal Aids Increase the Effectiveness of ‘Best Practice’ Verbal Interview Techniques? An Experimental StudyApplied Cognitive Psychology, 2011
- Does drawing facilitate older children's reports of emotionally laden events?Applied Cognitive Psychology, 2011
- Drawings as memory aids: Optimising the drawing method to facilitate young children's recallApplied Cognitive Psychology, 2010
- The cognitive interview: the efficacy of a modified mental reinstatement of context procedure for frontline police investigatorsApplied Cognitive Psychology, 2008
- Recalling an event one year later: the impact of props, drawing and a prior interviewApplied Cognitive Psychology, 2000